Some members of the state Senate want to give convicted criminals a second chance. A bill passed the Senate’s Judiciary Committee Friday that would create the possibility of expungement for some non-violent felony crimes.

The bill would give an opportunity for the person convicted to file for expungement five years after completing his or her sentence. Supporters say only non-violent convictions would be considered, like drug crimes.

West Virginia currently has expungement options for misdemeanor crimes but not felonies.

Sen. Donald Cookman, D-Hampshire, who was a circuit judge before his appointment to the Senate, said a second chance should be provided in some cases.

“When someone is convicted of one offense how much is enough? How long do we punish that person? How long do we keep them being a responsible citizen?¬†” Cookman asked.

The person would have to petition the circuit court and prove to a circuit judge that they have been rehabilitated and are a law-abiding citizen.

The circuit judge would make the final decision but the convicted felon would have to meet what’s called an “enhanced burden of proof.”

“It has to go to the circuit court and it has to be proven by clear and convincing evidence that the person has changed and they are entitled to this relief,” Sen. Cookman said.

Sen. David Nohe, R-Wood,¬†told the committee in his former position as a police officer he arrested a man on a drug charge that he wishes he hadn’t.

“He immediately went to work, became a pillar of our community and there were days I couldn’t sleep. When I look back on the arrest, I ruined his life instead of counseling him,” Nohe said.

The bill (SB365) is now before the full Senate for consideration.


bubble graphic


bubble graphic


  • Roger

    When I first saw this headline, I began to laugh out loud. I thought the legislature was voting for a bill that would erase their record. Their legislative work is embarrassing enough that I could see how they'd want the record erased.

  • Curmudgeon

    This is a good bill. I personally know a kid (20 year old) who recently messed up and stole (shoplifted) $1500 worth of electronics. Although he gave it all back and fully cooperated with police and waived his hearing - it is still a felony. He seems remorseful and is taking his punishment of probation without complaint.
    I hope he turns things around. If he does, I hate to see the life sentence of a felony conviction stay with this young man his whole life.


    This is a good bill. Certain drug crimes, as listed in this proposal, should not be subjected to a lifelong punishment and loss of ones ability to re-enter society and return to their profession if desired. This is a good bill.

  • thornton

    Perhaps, IT eventually does pay.

  • Martinsburg Resident

    Senator David Nohe....sounds to me like you were responsible for helping to turn his life around (his arrest)... he was already in the process of ruining it! Crime has consequences. Although sounds like this bill would help the few that actually turn their life around.