MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — Monongalia County Circuit Judge Russell Clawges is set to hear arguments Tuesday morning concerning several motions filed by the attorney for a teenage girl accused of first degree murder.

Shelia Eddy, 18, was indicted for first degree murder in the death of Skylar Neese, in July 2012.  Eddy has pleaded not guilty.  Among the motions, her attorney is requesting the indictment be dismissed, and if there is a trial, it be moved to another venue.

The motions suggest that Eddy’s attorney, Michael Benninger, is preparing to question the credibility of the state’s star witness.

Benninger argues in one of his filings that Shoaf was “suffering from a diagnosed mental illness at the time she made incriminating statements” concerning herself and Eddy.

Neese disappeared from her Star City home in July 2012. Her body was found nine months later about 30 miles away, just across the Pennsylvania state line.  The motive for the killing has still not been released.

Eddy’s change of venue motion argues that she “cannot obtain a fair and impartial trial in Monongalia County due to the existence of substantial publicity and prejudice presently existing against the defendant.”

Other filings include:

–A motion for the state to provide all statements and evidence provided by Rachel Shoaf to the police, including any offers for immunity that were made to Shoaf.   Benninger contends in his filing that Shoaf “was laboring under extreme emotional distress, anxiety and duress and/or suffering from a diagnosed mental illness at the time she made incriminating statements concerning herself and defendant Shelia Eddy.”

–A motion to dismiss the indictment against Eddy, claiming that investigators “engaged in substantial prosecutorial misconduct” through their contact with Eddy before she was indicated.

–A motion to delay a scheduled October 15th pre-trial hearing to give the defense more time to file additional motions and continue gathering evidence.

–A motion for the prosecution to turn over all relevant evidence it has obtained, including a list of state witnesses and alleged co-conspirators.

Eddy has remained in jail since her arrest earlier this year.


bubble graphic


bubble graphic


  • Karisa

    I hate the smug look on her face. She will get all she deserves when she meets her Maker.

  • mauldawg

    Now it is so easy to see why lawyers are some of the worlds scum. All this lawyer wants is to draw out the trial and pocket a few more dollars. This girl needs to spend the rest of her life in prison. Maybe get a cell next to her lawyer.

  • WV

    Wow her attorney is going for the jugular. Good luck with that. She will be charged with something. She isn't walking out of court with a clean sweep. Her attorney seems like a pretentious d-bag.

  • D.P.

    This POS sure is going to be a FAVORITE with the other prisoners! Hopefully, for a LONG, LONG TIME!!!!!


    Burn her at the stake!