MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – Dana Holgorsen called it a game “we should have won” and some of his players mistakenly felt they already had.

After transforming an early 13-point deficit into an 11-point third-quarter lead, West Virginia celebrated too soon. And No. 16 Texas Tech responded with closing surge of its own, reeling off the final 21 points in a 37-27 win.

“We thought we had this game,” said receiver Kevin White. “But we didn’t keep the gas on them. We just let off a little bit, and you can’t do that in the Big 12. Those (Texas Tech) guys were good, but I thought we were better.”

Our unit-by-unit evaluation of Saturday’s loss, which dropped the Mountaineers to 3-4 overall and 1-3 in league play:

Ben Queen/MetroNews photo

Clint Trickett and the WVU offense produce zero points on its final five series.


The most apparent sign Clint Trickett has a better grasp of “putting the ball in play” was his willingness to make more underneath throws. A 41-percent passer coming in, he connected on 27-of-43 for 254 yards and made a sharp read to find Charles Sims on a short TD.
Three times, however, Trickett missed open receivers, including a third-and-4 pass he threw low and left of Ronald Carswell at the marker. That misfire came amid WVU’s string of five fruitless possessions that closed the game.
“When times mattered most, we didn’t play situations as good as we should have—me included,” Trickett said.
Dreamius Smith compiled a career-high 89 yards on 16 carries, showing exceptional vision and cutback ability on scoring runs of 38 and 12 yards.
The junior college transfer’s 5.6 yards per carry was a tick better than the 5.1 of Charles Sims, whose 77-yard day was tempered by his second lost fumble of the season. Sims popped a 16-yard run from his own 1 that was a shoestring tackle away from being a 99-yarder. (Cody Clay’s seal block on the edge sprang it.)
Continuing to be utilized in the passing game, Sims made seven receptions for 32 yards, including a 4-yard touchdown on a sideline catch after going in motion.
Third-string freshman Wendell Smallwood did not have a carry but turned his only catch into a 13-yard gain. Clay also had a 9-yard grab, his seventh of the season.

Ben Queen/Metronews photo

Daikiel Shorts (6) celebrates a score with Charles Sims. The pair combined for 16 catches in the 37-27 loss to Texas Tech.


White’s five-catch 77-yard game warrants an asterisk, considering he drew three 15-yard pass interference flags against Tech’s Olaoluwa Falemi and a holding call against Bruce Jones. His 40-yard leaping reception over 5-foot-10 safety Tanner Jacobson was a key play on WVU’s 99-yard second-quarter scoring drive.
The highest-degree-of-difficulty catch went to Daikiel Shorts, who wrestled down a 22-yard jump ball over Terrance Bullitt. Though Shorts made nine grabs for 78 yards, he also inappropriately broke off a corner route on the infamous fourth-and-14 incompletion (see coaching).
Targeted only three times, Carswell had a single catch for 18 yards. In the fourth quarter, he missed a crucial block on a quick-screen to Shorts that went for no gain.
Mario Alford, after moving from slot to outside receiver, caught one pass on a 15-yard slant and was targeted once more on a deep sideline incompletion into the end zone. He also ran an end around for minus-2 yards as WVU futilely tried to get off the deck in the fourth quarter.
Jordan Thompson (two catches for 12 yards) had a drop in the closing seconds.
After Texas Tech allowed 3.1 yards per rush through six games, WVU averaged 4.7. But the line’s most productive performance of the season took a nosedive after left guard Quinton Spain left with an apparent right leg injury at 1:31 of the third quarter.
“We scared them early, and we were doing things downfield early, so they kept the safeties back a lot in the second half,” Holgorsen said. “We were unable to block man-on-man in the last quarter and a half, which is discouraging, disheartening.”
Asked if Spain’s absence explained the late-game struggles (9 yards on the final six carries), Holgorsen replied: “Probably, but suck it up.”
WVU allowed two sacks, including one in the fourth quarter when left tackle Nick Kindler was beaten off edge by sophomore linebacker Pete Robertson, result in in a Trickett fumble and a 7-yard loss.
WVU wasted a scoring threat early, facing second-and-5 at the Texas Tech 15, when Pat Eger committed a personal foul coming to the aid of Thompson (who was being stood up and popped by defenders). Two plays later, Mark Glowinski hooked a defender on a trap block and drew a holding penalty. That all set up the fourth-and-14 scenario from the 26 (really, see coaching).
Texas Tech’s 3.6 yards per carry was nominal, and right on pace with its season average. But during the final 4:43, when trying to construct a game-clinching drive, Tech ran four straight times for 31 yards and two crucial first downs.
But the real shortcoming Saturday was WVU’s lack of a pass rush—a responsibility the defensive front shares with the linebackers. On 52 drop-backs, Red Raiders freshman Davis Webb was never sacked and was hurried only six times (liberal application of the term “hurry”). Four of those hurries still resulted in positive yardage: twice Webb tucked it for short gains, twice he completed throws.
Davis, making his second start in place of the injured Baker Mayfield, threw for 462 yards on 36-of 50 passing. The kid looked less like a second-team rookie and more like Seth Doege reincarnated.
“I just can’t believe the efficiency in which that kid throws the ball,” said WVU defensive coordinator Keith Patterson. “It’s like the guy has been starting since Aug. 1.
“Every time we tried to zone pressure it seemed like they had the perfect call. He understands what he wants to do with the ball. There’s no hesitation. When his reads aren’t there, he pulls it down and runs.”
Dontrill Hyman and Shaq Rowell (three tackles each) weren’t disruptive enough, and Will Clarke was invisible, held without a tackle until the final three minutes. Kyle Rose made two stops in a backup role.
Nick Kwiatkoski, the unit’s most dynamic playmaker this season, returned from a two-game absence (hamstring) to make eight tackles. He was just inches shy from making two stops on Texas Tech touchdowns.
His diving-over-the-pile hit stopped Kenny Williams cold in the third quarter (though refs ruled the tip of the ball crossed the goal line). The converted high school safety then was unable to cover tight end Jace Amaro on a 10-yard TD pass with 61 seconds left.
“Nick was in good position, had inside leverage on the coverage, and (Webb) just kind of tubed it inside,” said Patterson. “The ball’s right there on the money.”
Amaro caught a much easier touchdown in the first period when Buck linebacker Brandon Golson left him uncovered on third-and-3 from the 10. The linebackers and safeties were unable to inhibit Amaro, who compiled a nine-catch, 136-yard day.
Jared Barber made a team-high nine tackles, 1.5 TFLs and deflected a third-down pass, while Doug Rigg added five stops and Golson four. Isaiah Bruce made only two tackles, but his third-down pressure forced an incompletion that held the Raiders to a first-quarter field goal. Bruce later made the WVU defensive play of the day—granted, there weren’t many candidates—by forcing and recovering a Webb goal-line fumble that prevented the game from becoming a runaway with Tech leading 13-3 in the second period.

Joe Sadlek/All-Pro Photography

Kenny Williams ran for 58 yards and two TDs on 16 carries for Texas Tech.


Not nearly so balanced as Baylor, Texas Tech asked its quarterback to win the game and Webb delivered in his first collegiate road start. Having surrendered 858 passing yards in its past two games, WVU ranks next to last in the conference in passing defense (257 yards per game) and last in yards per attempt (8.1).
Freshman Daryl Worley, elevated to starter over Travis Bell at field cornerback, had his hands full matched up against Bradley Marquez (eight catches for 112 yards). For the most part, Worley was fundamentally sound, except for a 30-yard first-quarter completion on which he rolled up toward the line and let Marquez get free deep.
Worley, WVU’s most physically imposing corner, also was blocked into infinity by Tech freshman receiver Reginald Davis on a 27-yard catch-and-run by DeAndre Washington.
Bell played frequently as a backup and had his own struggles against Marquez and Eric Ward.
Karl Joseph (five tackles) was the victim of a well designed third-and-1 playcall on which Williams faked a left-side dive and caught a short pass that went for 41 yards.
Darwin Cook (seven tackles) warranted and received a 15-yard flag for a late hit against Amaro on an overthrown pass.
After K.J. Dillon let Amaro run free for a 24-yarder, the nickel back played solid coverage to no avail on a 32-yard completion.
Seldom-used corner Avery Williams was victimized by slot receiver Jordan Davis on a 27-yard catch that led to Tech’s game-sealing score.

Ben Queen/MetroNews photo

WVU’s Terrell Chestnut forces a Texas Tech fumble on a first-half kick return.


During West Virginia’s midgame surge, Terrell Chestnut stripped Tech’s Austin Stewart on a kick return and Brandon Napoleon recovered at the Red Raiders’ 15. That set up a field goal that squared the game at 13-all.
WVU later allowed a 52-yard kick return by Reginald Davis, while its own runbacks were underwhelming at 17 yards per.
Nick O’Toole’s 42.6-yard punting average included a long off 55 and two inside the 20. He didn’t provide his typical hang time, but Tech managed essentially nothing two returns and WVU continues to top the Big 12 in net punting (42.0).
Josh Lambert made both field-goal attempts, from 33 and 30 yards respectively, and should have attempted a 43-yarder in the first quarter if not for the most nonsensical fourth-down gamble of Holgorsen’s career..
Let’s address the obvious question: What in the name of Charlie Weis was Holgorsen thinking on fourth-and-14 from the Texas Tech 26? WVU trailed only 10-0 with one minute left in the first quarter. Hardly the time to panic. After Trickett floated a 30-yard spiral to an empty corner of the end zone, the entire stadium was asking “Whaaaaaaaat?”
Holgorsen later admitted, “I do regret that decision. I should’ve kicked it.” Still, such a low-percentage play demands deeper explanation. And Holgorsen’s explanation only made the decision murkier.
“I just saw (Texas Tech) take it right down and score two times in a row, so I figured that touchdowns were going to be important,” Holgorsen said. He apparently missed the part where Tech had deemed a field goal plenty important by taking one on fourth-and-goal at the 4.
“We should have kicked the field goal,” Holgorsen reiterated, “but it was fourth-and-2, or whatever it was, and we were moving the ball good.”
Whatever it was most certainly was not fourth-and-2, but rather fourth-and-14. Quite a difference there. Perhaps Holgorsen merely had a press conference slip of the tongue—as opposed to actually misjudging down-and-distance by such a ridiculous gap—but the resulting loss of three points was careless and certainly impacted the game late. (Recall that Texas Tech was leading by three when it put away the game with a late TD drive. Would the Red Raiders have been so confident in a tie-game situation? Would WVU’s last series have proceeded differently if the score was still a one-possession margin?)
Beyond the unfathomable fourth-down decision, Holgorsen and his staff also suffered a big-picture fail: Their inability to keep players level-headed and focused when they were rolling in the second half. WVU’s mindset shifted to cruise-control and Texas Tech regained momentum.
“We started feeling pretty good about ourselves in the middle of the third quarter, but the game wasn’t over,” Holgorsen admitted. Given the full-scale demolitions at Maryland and Baylor, how could WVU could fall susceptible to overconfidence against an unbeaten Top 25 team?
It was a lethal lapse. When Texas Tech counterpunched, West Virginia caved, showing yet again that a rebuilding team with a Proustian list of flaws may not be worthy of a 13th game this season.

Ben Queen/Metronews photo

Dana Holgorsen watched WVU squander a chance to upset Texas Tech.
bubble graphic


bubble graphic


  • Josh

    WVU is 5-10 over their last 15 games & two of those 5 wins are against 1AA opponents. Remember, Luck fired Stewart because 9-3 seasons while not playing for titles was unacceptable. I guess now it is.

    • Mister Man

      Luck didn't fire Stewart because of a 9-3 record.

      • tw eagle

        AD Luck replaced Stewart because he couldn't get enough talented athletes to
        come to WVU . . .Holgerson is getting the
        athletes here in Morgantown , he's getting
        them coached up , but their play resembles his coaching style -UNDISCIPLINED . . .erratic . . . a gambler on 4th down when trailing , but he
        gave the tech game away by getting conservative when in the lead . . .his
        personal learning curve for becoming a
        competent HC has flatlined . . .I think he's
        seen the errors of his decisions but he seems incapable of learning and growing
        from the (his) teams failures . . .

  • Gene

    Oliver Luck, this was your call bringing in Holgorsen and then giving him a contract extension. As a business man, would you say you are getting your monies worth? The Mountaineer nation deserves better......

  • Bryan

    Sure WVU coaches and players made mistakes that could have cost WVU their second upset of the season, however should TT not get credit for doing what they should and being the favorite and now #10 team in the country dig deeper than the underdog and find a way to win.

  • Bobby M

    They say a teams personally IS a reflection of head coaches! Well I AGREE because this team acts like there coach! Just so blah BLAH blah about everything MATTER of facts bull crap and I dont see it getting ANY better anytime soon! Tell me WHAT good thing do YOU see on the HORIZONS now? NOTHING! Bad offense line, soft WRs, NO running game, CRAPOLA defense, what could POSSIBLY change!????!! During the game on saturday I'll tell you WHO I did NOT see on the sidelines that was Superman he was NOT there! So nobody is coming to SAVE this team and I'm offically in Crankyville because this program has NOSE DIVED straight back to earth!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Fire Hogo

    Dear Mr. Luck: Please fire Holgorsen before leaving for Texas. You created this mess, please fix it. If you care anything about your alma mater.......

  • Tom from Vienna

    The field goal attempt was early. It meant nothing. Our kickoff returns were ill-judged. Take a knee. Wide receivers don't fight and rarely block. QB play was marginal, good short passes but floaters otherwise. What happened to Millard?

    • Bobby M

      FG attempt meant nothing!!!???? Are YOU crazy!!!! Go tell Don Nehlen putting points on the BOARD early means NOTHING!!! Every point that goes ON that board changes the CHESS BOARD Friend! Not ONLY does the field goal early mean SOMETHING but EVERY SINGLE PLAY means something! Every ONE! Every bad snap every dropped pass every trip every miss tackle every penalty! Its all connected AND surprised I am you DONT see such things!

      • Uncle Unctuous

        Surprised I am that Yoda would SHOUT so much. Out of character it is.

      • Steve

        I agree. Don't chase points later. Get them when you can.

  • pcm

    I wonder who the play caller is, Holgorsen? Shannon Dawson? Is that a shared responsibility?

    Assuming a shared responsibility, I would at least change the OC next season if not sooner.

    Going for broke on 4th and 14 in TTU territory in first quarter is a violation of common sense... that is Football 101.

    Here's to hoping Santa will give
    "Football for Dummies" to both Dana and Shannon fir Christmas.

  • TC

    I have been patiently allowing Coach Holgorson to "learn" to become a head coach at this level. Simply not happening. He wastes timeouts, cannot decide week to week on a QB, goes for it on 4th down way too often, seems to panic easily, and doesn't show the composure of a head coach. I think the players see that and react the same way. We need a change. We need someone with state ties who cares about the state and program and has some experience as a head coach or coordinator.

    • Richard


      I have said many times. We do not need to hire coordinators. There will always be a viable head coach at a lower conference level to come to WV.

    • RJ

      Yes! Wouldn't it be nice if Jimbo Fisher or Nick Saben would feel homesick? Face it, we need a good head coach that can recruit top players to come. The Big 12 is no Big East or American Athletic Conference, if we don't start getting good players/coaches, Mountaineer Nation can only expect to be a lower tier team in the Big 12, they are serious about winning programs.

      • Shawn H

        It was reported on the message boards that Jimbo Fisher was offered the job and accepted. Supposedly, his family was telling people they were coming back to WV. The WVU leadership changed their minds and decided they did not want to pay the buyout. We got Bill Stewart instead. Don't know if it is true or not, but it is certainly an interesting rumor.

    • Bryan

      I must be slipping, Rich Rodriguez WV born ex-WV coach left for a better job after the greatest three year run in WVU history. If this doesn't throw out the "state ties" then nothing will.

    • Bryan

      Agree with a lot of what you think but what does state ties have to do with it? Some assistants do. State ties, Saban WV born Alabama coach, Jimbo Fisher WW born Florida St coach, Don Nehlen Ohio born ex-WV coach, Lou Holtz WV born coached everywhere but WV, don't understand this "state ties" thing so many spout out, it's really irrelevant.

      • Rick S.

        I think Bryan is correct about the prior state ties being irrelevant. What is important is that the coach be "all-in" to the program and embrace WVU and the state and make a 100% commitment to the program. Just to be clear, I am not saying that Holgorsen has not made that commitment -- maybe he has, maybe he hasn't, I don't know. I am saying that any coach needs to make the commitment, whether it be/was Nehlen, Rodriguez, Stewart, Holgorsen, or whomever.

        • Bryan

          Nice post Rick and I totally agree, as for Holgorsen I also agree with you and not sure but I think he's heading that direction. I also think that he would like to get things turned around and develop into a good HC if for no other reason than to be in the talks for big jobs as they become available.

  • JHT

    Dang it.....They flat let that one get away. They will learn from it but it still stings. I have not given up on our coach either. I dont expect this season to produce the 6 wins to get a bowl bid, but we Mounty fans must continue to support the team and show the "young" players what being apart of the Mountaineer nation is all about.

  • clark

    Horrible coaching says it all.

    A good team starts at the top. Now you know why WVU isn't very good. And it never will be under Dana.

    Good OC? Probably.

    Good head coach? Absolutely not.

  • William

    Fire this joker ASAP!

    • Elliott

      Your fired!

  • Neal

    Good stock report. It's not hard to imagine why our team, and especially the defense, would lose confidence in themselves when you do things like go for a 4th and 14 when you could kick a make able field goal only down 10 in the 1 st quarter. The HC displays a lack of understanding of field position football. It almost seems like he would prefer a 70-63 game as opposed to anything else. You don't build a solid program when you coach this way. The decision to go for a 4th and two on our own side of the field when we were still in the Baylor game also falls in the same category. After that decision the game was decided in the 1st quarter.

  • steve

    Here's the next question-Who is the next head coach? Jim Tressel?

    • Big Larry

      Jim Tressel...

      I like it!

    • Rick S.

      With the sanctions the NCAA levied against Tressel, I am not sure if he is a viable option to ever coach college football again. But he was a tremendous coach and there is no doubt in my mind that he would be successful wherever he would go, if he is ever permitted to coach again. Let me also be clear by saying that I am not endorsing Tressel to come in and replace Holgorsen, because Holgorsen is our coach and I am not calling for him to be fired. I am just stating an independent opinion about Tressel.

      • DWM

        The tatoo parlors in Mon County heartily endorse your suggestion.

        In all seriousness, Tressel is in a, what I think the NCAA refers to as "Show Cause" period, meaning that to be hired, WVU would have to explain to the NCAA their reasoning and would invite higher scrutiny. I think he is a good coach and would be a terrific hire.

        That being said, I would want Holgerson to have the full opportunity to be the head coach and I think that means he should get this year and next to turn it around. He is still thinking like an O coordinator and not like a head coach.

        My guess is that we'll finish 5-7 this year and baring the unforseen, 9-3 next year. The team is young and will get better.

  • Rick

    It was a good game regardless of outcome. Showed me a lot...even that the coach didn't throw a temper tantrum...first time he acted like a coach...although he has a long way to go, it was a start.

    • Truthteller

      Only cowards don't have emotions.

  • Joe

    Good morning, Allan.

    Agree with stock report, specifically the coaching section comments.

    • Moon

      Concur also. The 4th down call was a puzzler, but what really gets my goat is our defensive passiveness. We need to watch some Buddy Ryan film...put some pressure on the young quarterbacks we are facing. Pressure makes up for average/bad coverage. Great coverage does not make up for no pressure. A good college quarterback with time will find an open receiver. A good quarterback with no time will make mistakes. PRESSURE. Attack!