The full state Senate will consider a bill expanding West Virginia’s fledgling charter schools system.
The bill passed the Senate Education Committee during a long meeting that started Tuesday afternoon and concluded in the evening. The House of Delegates has already passed the bill.
Charter schools would be part of the state’s public education system and would be given greater latitude in exchange for the possibility of losing their right to operate if they fail.
House Bill 2012 would increase the number that could be approved. So far, West Virginia has no charter schools. The bill also would lay the groundwork for charter schools that would operate virtually.
“I’d like to see if they’re successful. I’d like to see a couple of them and whether they actually work. Ten is a lot,” said Senator Mike Romano, D-Harrison.
Romano offered an amendment that would initially allow three charter schools before eventually allowing up to 10. He also proposed a cap of 1,500 virtual charter school students.
The amendment was narrowly approved by the committee, 7-6.
Right now, county school boards may authorize a charter school. This bill would add a West Virginia Professional Charter School Board as an authorizer.
Applicants with a rejected charter proposal have 30 days after that to appeal to the state Board of Education.
Two years ago, West Virginia legislators passed a bill making many changes to the state’s education system, including the allowance of charter schools.
West Virginia’s charter schools structure did need some changes, said Veronica D. Brooks-Uy, interim vice president of policy at the National Association of Charter School Authorizers, which describes itself as an independent voice for effective charter school policy and thoughtful charter authorizing practices.
Those include expanding authorizing options beyond school districts, allowing a number beyond three initial schools and equitable funding.
“All in all it made sense that West Virginia would revisit its original charter law,” Brooks-Uy said last week on MetroNews’ “Talkline.”
But there are three areas she described as “a no-go.”
The first is how special education is handled. She expressed concern about a provision of the bill allowing charters to prevent students with an IEP from enrolling hinging on a discussion with the child’s family. She called that “counseling out” and said it’s inequitable and illegal.
“Charter schools are public schools and therefore they have to serve all students, including students with exceptionalities. Full stop.”
The second how virtual charter schools are handled. The organization is concerned that the way this bill is written, virtual charter schools could operate essentially without competition.
“Further, while the bill does include an enrollment cap on virtual charter schools, it is simply too large and too vague to be effective,” the organization wrote in a blog post.
The third is how to handle instances of financial mismanagement. Sometimes, she said, an authorizer may need to revoke a contract before it’s up. “This is rare, but we do know it has happened before,” she said.
She described a possible situation with “a bad operator — rare — who is misusing public dollars.”
Veronica D. Brooks-Uy, Interim Vice President of Policy at NACSA, talks with @HoppyKercheval about their opposition to the charter school bill in West Virginia. WATCH: https://t.co/wkudfIRZCB pic.twitter.com/5Bz3WbHpLd
— MetroNews (@WVMetroNews) February 17, 2021