Sheriff: 2 people killed before Lost Creek fire

LOST CREEK, W.Va. — Harrison County Sheriff Robert Matheny said the investigation into an apparent murder-arson is his department’s top priority.

Harrison County Sheriff Robert Matheny

Matheny detailed the progress and path of their probe during a Wednesday appearance on MetroNews “Talkline.”

“We have mobilized all of our detectives and we have a lot of resources, including the state Fire Marshal’s Office,” Matheny said.

The investigation began at around 5 a.m. last Saturday when firefighters on the scene notified the Harrison County Sheriff’s Department that there were two bodies in the basement of the burning home on Good Hope Pike near Lost Creek. Matheny would not elaborate, but said are fairly certain they know who the victims are.

“We believe we know who they are, but that’s for the state Medical Examiner to determine,” Matheny said. “As you would understand, when we release that we want to be positive of who they are.”

The State Medical Examiner has determined the two victims were not victims of the fire, but no other information about possible trauma has been released.

“The cause of death is homicide, at this time we’re not releasing the manner of death,” Matheny said. “We’re still somewhat early in this complex investigation.”

Unconfirmed reports indicate witnesses reported a vehicle leaving the residence after a large boom. Crews battled the fire for more than two hours.

“As days go on and we uncover more information I’m confident we’ll come up with some sort of resolution,” Matheny said.

Information about the crime can be left by calling 304-255-7867.

More News

One dead in I-64 wreck
Crash happened Sunday evening.
June 4, 2023 - 11:00 pm
Nicholas County Schools still trying to navigate impact of flood 7 years later
Money issues threaten rebuild of flooded schools.
June 4, 2023 - 7:16 pm
Low-interest loans available to 2022 flood victims in select counties
The Disaster Loan Outreach Center is located at Belle Town Hall located at 1100 E. Dupont Avenue.
June 4, 2023 - 5:04 pm
A watch party to be held for acclaimed Charleston chef, Paul Smith as he takes the national stage
For the first time in West Virginia history, a West Virginia culinary artist, Chef Paul Smith is vying for the title of Best Chef: Southeast at the James Beard Awards in Chicago.
June 4, 2023 - 4:00 pm