6:00pm: Sportsline with Tony Caridi

North Carolina man faces serious poaching charges in W.Va.

WELCH, W.Va. — A North Carolina man faces a list of poaching violations in West Virginia and if convicted, the price tag for illegally killing two trophy bucks in the Mountain State could be substantial.

The suspect, from Statesville, N.C., faces charges of killing two trophy bucks in McDowell County on two separate days in November 2020. West Virginia Natural Resources Police, who have not yet released the identity of the suspect, received information which indicated the bucks were taken in violation of the law.

“Like a lot of things the investigation started with help from people in the community. That’s our greatest resource for information. We received information of possibly two bucks being taken illegally,” said Natural Resources Police Officer Jonathan Gills in McDowell County.

According to Gills, once they learned the suspect was from North Carolina they reached out to officers with the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission.

“They were a HUGE help to us,” said Gills.

Officers from the two agencies were able to come up with photographs and other physical evidence in the case which proved both bucks were killed in West Virginia. Turned out one of the bucks in question was actually checked in as being killed in North Carolina. Now, North Carolina investigators are closely watching the West Virginia case and the individual will likely face charges in his home state as well.

Gills said the evidence also showed both bucks were killed with a crossbow. McDowell County is one of West Virginia’s four archery-only hunting counties. Unlike the rest of West Virginia, crossbows are not allowed in those four archery-only counties unless the hunter has a Class Y hunting permit. According to Gills, the suspect did not have such an exemption. The archery counties also have a limit of one buck per season, taking the second buck also constituted a violation.

The two deer have extremely recognizable antler features and Gills believed it is very likely other hunters in McDowell County have trail cam pictures of them.

“Both deer have highly identifiable key features,” he explained. “Somebody who hunts is going to be able to look at that deer and know if they’ve seen it before.”

Some of those pictures are part of the case.

“We’ve been sent a lot of photos and there are a lot of folks who are upset these deer were taken,” he explained.

Natural Resources Police said they also expect they’ll get many more pictures of the two bucks on the hoof as word of their demise gets out.

The charges against the suspect, so far, include two counts of hunting without permission on the lands of another. According to Gills, both bucks were killed on a hunting lease where the suspect was not permitted to hunt. He also will face two counts of illegal possession of wildlife. Two counts of hunting with a crossbow without a Class Y Permit. Additionally he’s charged with one count of hunting after obtaining a legal limit, one count of violation of one deer allowed in a bow county, and since he didn’t have an extra buck stamp he’s charged with a single count of hunting without proper permits.

If convicted, the fines and court costs could be substantial, but the calculation of those costs will be up to the Magistrate. However, under the state’s enhanced trophy buck regulations, the replacement costs for taking the two bucks illegally will certainly be substantial. The replacement cost for any deer killed illegally in West Virginia is $500. However, since these two are trophy status, the figures ramp way up. According to Gills, the replacement cost for these two deer, both of which are Pope and Young Record Book caliber, will be in the range of $15,000.

The Legislature a year ago increased those replacement costs for trophy bucks. Gills said it was a major weapon to deter poaching of big bucks in his county.

“Our department was given a great asset with that. Basically, they’re stealing the deer. They’re stealing quality bucks from legitimate hunters; men, women, and kids who are trying to go out and enjoy the sport,” Gills said.

So far, no court date for the suspect had been set.

More Outdoors

Putnam County hunter's miss was the key on a cold, rainy afternoon
Brett Walker of Buffalo, W.Va. says he was so cold, he missed his first buck, but later in the day was able to close the deal on a much, much bigger whitetail.
November 25, 2023 - 12:01 am
Special trout stockings to happen on two Webster County waters
The Elk River and the catch and release section on Back Fork of Elk in Webster Counties will get special stockings in November and December to see just how much to a tourism draw they will create for the area
November 22, 2023 - 1:56 pm
A hot afternoon produced a massive Gilmer County buck
Despite a warm day, a glimpse of the big buck he was after prompted Herb Miller to head to his hunting blind not far from home in a hunt he'll not soon forget
November 22, 2023 - 12:01 am
Deer hunters find success on opening day
West Virginia DNR biologists and wildlife managers spend opening day collecting biological samples from deer in four counties.
November 20, 2023 - 1:38 pm