SANDSTONE, W.Va. — Cody Harrah of Sandstone, W.Va. entered the 2024 archery hunting season with severe doubts about the buck he had been after for the past five years.
“We’ve played cat and mouse and up until this November, he won the game every year. I’ve lost a lot of sleep over this deer. He just became too smart for me really. I honestly gave up hunting him this year. My dad, my brother, and my uncle all had him on camera on that side of the ridge I used to hunt. I told them, ‘Good Luck!'” said Cody in an interview for West Virginia Outdoors.
The buck which had become his “white whale” he nicknamed “Houdini.” He had never seen him in the daylight after the season opened.
“It’s crazy. He’d be there all summer and in velvet in the daylight and then when it gets to that time of the year, he’s gone. You’d only see him in the night time on your camera,” explained Cody with some frustration in his voice..
Listen to “Cody Harrah, big Summers County buck in 2024 archery season” on Spreaker.
Cody was so torn up over the big buck’s elusive streak he moved out of the territory. For the past four years, “Houdini” had only been only one side of a valley where Cody and his family hunted in Summers County. There were no pictures outside of that side of the ridge by anyone of this particular buck. The buck patrolled the steep hills from the top of the ridge to the creek at the bottom and moved along the hillside, but had never appeared to have broken the boundary of what he had evidently claimed as his own piece of ground. There was also no evidence anyone had tried to take it away from him.
“We noticed this year, he didn’t even really have any scarring or broken horns. We don’t think any other deer really challenged him. he had his pick of whatever he wanted,” he said.

Cody selected a spot on the opposite side of the valley and during scouting got a picture of a nice buck. It was hard to tell much about the buck other than it had a nice set of antlers. He never lifted his head to where there was a good, full on shot of his features.
Cody got a call from a buddy in early November who had just killed a nice buck and thought it was Houdini. Turned out when they looked him over, it wasn’t the buck with the extremely long G-2 tines which had lived rent free in Cody’s head for five straight seasons. That buck–had escaped again.
Cody slipped into his stand on November 16th in the morning hours. He watched several bucks swagger by. A couple of eight pointers walked and a smaller buck. It was enough to prove the rut was active and the bucks were chasing. About 8:30 a doe came hustling by. Cody instinctively knew a buck would be trailing her. Sure enough, he heard something coming and saw nothing but tines moving through the underbrush.
“I grabbed my bow and one of the cams caught the front of the tree stand and it spooked him a little. He bounded up the hill a little and put his head back down like he was going to keep chasing those does,” explained Cody. “I had three shooting lanes and he just happened to stop in one of them.”
Cody let the arrow fly and it hit a little further back than he had hoped. The big buck took off, but headed up the hill. Cody was able to watch him through his binoculars.
“He went about 10 yards and he started getting a wide stance. I started to think maybe he was hit better than I first thought. He bedded down and when he turned his head is when I realized, this was the buck I had been chasing for five years. I didn’t want to get down right away, but man when I figured that out, I couldn’t get down. I was really torn up,” he recalled.
Cody sat and stared at the big buck which was on the ground not far away. He put the range finder on him at 53 yards and kept watching. After about a half hour, the big whitetail tried to stand and move, but by then his strength was gone. He staggered, fell, and rolled down the hill. He came to rest motionless and the last gasps life slipped out of his massive body. Cody sat in his stand dumfounded. Moments later, when he finally made his way to the buck’s side, the cascade of emotions washed over him.
“I cried. I couldn’t believe it was finally over and I was finally sitting there holding this deer. I’ve laid in bed many, many nights thinking about people I see posting pictures every year about these bucks they’ve been chasing for years. I wondered if I was ever going to get my chance to do that. It was emotional. I mean, it’s the biggest deer I’ve ever killed in my life,” he said.

