Listen Now: MetroNews Midday
2:06pm: MetroNews Hotline

Hunting is Not Enough — NWTF

Photo: Eddie Ferrari 

It’s more than just allowing hunting according to the National Wild Turkey Federation in the ongoing discussion about whether thousands of acres of National Forest in West Virginia should become National Park Service lands.    Cully McCurdy is a biologist for NWTF and the West Virginia State Chapter of the organization.   Speaking on West Virginia Outdoors last Saturday, McCurdy indicated it’s not enough just to "allow hunting."

"It seems like the focus of everyone’s intent has been ‘Hunting will be allowed.’  That seems to be the catchphrase for everything," McCurdy said. "Hunting is not enough."

The Turkey Federation opposes the idea amid fears the current active management of federal lands for game and non-game wildlife will be lost. 

"Hunting is just a tool for managing wildlife and without the act of management on these areas to enhance habitat, it’s all for naught," he said.

The "active management" McCurdy refers to is creating wildlife openings or linear openings in the forest.   The West Virginia DNR works now with the US Forest Service to timber small tracts of acreage to be seeded or will seed old logging roads with grass to create linear openings and allow young turkeys and other birds to thrive. 

Young turkey poults along with grouse, warblers, and other song birds need the openings to survive and thrive.   The young birds must have a near 100-percent protein diet during the first weeks of life, the protein is found almost exclusively in open and grassy fields in the form of grasshoppers and other bugs.   Without those, brood production suffers.

McCurdy fears Park Service designation would also impact other recreational hunting activities, like bear hunting which is highly popular in the areas being targeted in the ongoing reconnaissance study.

"The best way to hunt bears is with hounds.  To do that you need large uninterrupted tracts of land to be efficient," McCurdy said. "Once you start limiting these lands, it won’t take very many complaints for the Park Service to create more safe areas or eliminate hunting."

McCurdy said regardless of what’s written into any park creation, the Park Service still has the authority to regulate hunting on property it controls.  He says without bear hunting, the bear problems experienced in the Great Smokey Mountains National Park will pale in comparison to the potential problems in a habitat as fertile for bears as the Allegheny Highlands in West Virginia.

Like many other sporting groups, NWTF leadership sees little to gain by shifting from one federal agency to another–and in fact believe the protection actually decreases.

"The attempt is to take management out of a natural resource based agency and put it into basically a social agency," said McCurdy. "The NPS do have biologist who do a lot of different work to help wildlife, but that’s not their emphasis. I just don’t think that’s the way to manage the forest at this time."

McCurdy says the NWTF is adamantly opposed to the idea of a National Park for the region and while he’s encouraged by US Senator Joe Manchin’s letter, McCurdy said he’s just as concerned about the future of the region as those trying to land the NPS designation. 

"Just as a preservationist should have the right to take their grandkids to view an undisturbed mountain vista, I should have the same right to take my grandkids down the road and have the opportunity to hear a golden wing warbler or a prairie warbler or grouse hunt," he said. "Without early successional habitat and progressive Silva culture treatments (logging) that’s not going to happen."

 





More Outdoors

Outdoors
Youth season produces an almost perfect 50-50 harvest
Youth hunters kill 1,383 antlered and 1,381 antlerless deer during the first season of the split youth hunting season
November 9, 2026 - 9:40 am
Outdoors
Teen Luke Stewart wins the BASS Nation State Championship
The senior at Clay County High School bested a crowded field which included some of West Virginias best bass fishermen.
November 8, 2026 - 2:37 pm
News
Bailey's resignation leaves a third vacancy on Natural Resources Commission
The seven member commission is down to four members as the final meeting of the year is scheduled for November
October 30, 2026 - 11:55 am
Outdoors
When his wife agreed to allow a hunt on their anniversary, an Upshur County hunter made it count
Kyler Doss had his eye on a big buck earlier in the archery season--and managed to talk his wife into allowing him to hunt on their anniversary. The request paid off.
October 28, 2026 - 1:33 pm


Your Comments