DNR to Study Potential Change at Stonewall

 

At one time the suggestion of a change in the catch and release regulation for bass on Stonewall Jackson Lake would have been considered the height of "bass blasphemy."   However, 25-years after the Lewis County impoundment was first flooded, the DNR is beginning to take a look at whether a change is in the best interest of the lake’s future.

Jim Walker, DNR fisheries biologist out of French Creek, tells MetroNews they plan to do a study on the black bass in the lake to determine their age and their size on average.  

"We’re going to look at length, weight, and age of the fish," said Walker. "If we see a sharp decline in the relative weight, which is what fisheries people refer to what a fish should weigh at a certain length, if that criteria doesn’t add up to what it should be, we MIGHT consider a regulation change."

Stonewall Jackson has long been a laboratory for big fish management.  Unlike other flood control lakes constructed in the 1950’s and ’60’s, Stonewall Jackson was flooded amid standing timber.    The catch and release regulation was implemented from day one on the impoundment in an effort to protect the bass and allow them to benefit from the over abundance of nutrients in the water during the first five to ten years of a new impoundment’s flooding.

The results were staggering.   Anglers learned the haunts of Stonewall bass and now expect to catch largemouth in the four to six pound range almost every trip depending on the time of year.    For years, it has been a bass fishing Utopia and the regulation was one of the factors credited for the success.  The same construction plan and regulations are in place on smaller impoundments around the state flooded since the 1986 creation of Stonewall. 

But, things never stay the same.  Walker says the catch and release regulation may have outlived its usefulness and may in fact be reaching a point of diminishing returns.

"We’re already seeing that in some of the weights of the fish.   They just aren’t as big and robust as they once were, granted there are still big fish in there, don’t get me wrong," he said. "But, the reservoir is about 25-years old so those older big bass, their maximum lifespan is 12 to 15 years.  Those we protected in the first five to six years are pretty much gone at this point."

The lake has been prolific and enabled females to successfully reproduce in abundance.  Biologists suspect the lake may now be reaching a level of having too many smaller bass to adequately support.   Officials fear the result, if left unchanged, could be an eventual uniform size to the bass and a lower average weight and length throughout the fishery.

"We want to manage the fishery the best we can with the current condition we’re dealing with," said Walker.

The change would enable bass anglers to remove some of the fish and possibly enable bass tournament organizers, for the first time in the lake’s history, to stage events on the water.   Although tournaments have a minimal impact on the bass decline, because of built in catch and release rules, the fish are still carried from where they are caught to a weigh-in site before being released back into the water.

Some anglers will cringe at the notion of keeping bass, particularly from Stonewall.  Walker knows the sensitivity surrounding the lake and says nothing will change until they’ve completed at least two years of the aging and size study.  He furthermore adds, the regulation change doesn’t necessarily mean it will be a wholesale opening of the water for harvest.

"That could be a slot limit or maybe a trophy bass regulation or maybe do something different with the catch and release to encourage the removal of small bass where they are stacked up on each other," he said.

The change would also require action by the Natural Resources Commission.  The commission, but design, would require heavy input from sportsmen before any such change is made. 

 





More Outdoors

Outdoors
Youth season produces an almost perfect 50-50 harvest
Youth hunters kill 1,383 antlered and 1,381 antlerless deer during the first season of the split youth hunting season
November 9, 2026 - 9:40 am
Outdoors
Teen Luke Stewart wins the BASS Nation State Championship
The senior at Clay County High School bested a crowded field which included some of West Virginias best bass fishermen.
November 8, 2026 - 2:37 pm
News
Bailey's resignation leaves a third vacancy on Natural Resources Commission
The seven member commission is down to four members as the final meeting of the year is scheduled for November
October 30, 2026 - 11:55 am
Outdoors
When his wife agreed to allow a hunt on their anniversary, an Upshur County hunter made it count
Kyler Doss had his eye on a big buck earlier in the archery season--and managed to talk his wife into allowing him to hunt on their anniversary. The request paid off.
October 28, 2026 - 1:33 pm


Your Comments