A few years ago the West Virginia Legislature and the state of West Virginia became, yet again, the punchline of jokes over what was at the time known as “The Road Kill Bill.”
Jay Leno and other national comedians lined up to tell their jokes about West Virginians who were now going to collect their supper off the double yellow line. They saw the stereotypical opportunity and couldn’t resist the temptation. West Virginians were angry about the mockery. It was understandable since almost every state has some form of wildlife law which enables a person to collect an animal they hit with an automobile.
The “road kill bill” eventually became law and it’s now legal to take home a wild animal you strike on the highway. You’re required to contact the Natural Resources Police and tell them about it. They will issue you a possession permit for the animal. The idea makes perfect sense. The resource is not wasted to rot on the highway or be hauled to the landfill by the Department of Highways at tax payers’ expense. The only critters you cannot keep are a spotted fawn or a bear cub, any other animal run over on the highway is yours if you want it.
I wonder if Jay Leno and the national comedians noticed Pennsylvania’s equivalent of the “road kill bill.” Greg Thompson of of Uniontown, Pennsylvania certainly did. He wasn’t laughing.
Thompson struck and killed a bear while driving along U.S. Route 119 near South Union Township in Fayette County, Pennsylvania. Thompson decided he’d like to keep the animal and have a rug made from its hide. He contacted the local game warden to inquire about a permit to make it legal. He was shocked to learn if he wanted to keep the bear, he’d have to pull out his wallet. Thompson tells Pittsburgh television station WPXI he would have to pay $100 to keep the bear.
“I shouldn’t have to pay a hundred bucks,” Thompson said. “They should have to pay my deductible.”
It turned out a little further research by the television station and Associated Press revealed the road kill game permits are quite a racket for the Pennsylvania Game Commission. The 100 dollar charge to keep the bear is just the tip of the iceberg. If you nail a big buck in the Keystone State with your automobile and want to hang on to the rack, which may be impaled on the grill of your vehicle, it will cost you an additional 10 dollars for every point on the buck’s head gear. If you’d like to keep the cape to have it mounted, throw in another 25 dollars. If you hit a fox, it will set you back a whopping 50 dollars.
I often hear people complain about the fees we pay in West Virginia for various privileges to hunt or fish and fund our Division of Natural Resources, but Pennsylvania crossed the line. It’s adding insult to injury. State Farm Insurance recently indicated the average cost of repairs for a car-deer collision is 3,000 dollars. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania wants to extract another couple hundred out of the poor motorist if they want to keep the offending animal’s carcass.
I’m betting few people in Pennsylvania even knew about this obscure fee. I’m sure those who proposed and pushed it through wanted it that way. It’s a glaring example of government overreach and abuse of the tax and fee structure.
West Virginia may have a lot of problems, but at the very least our state hasn’t stooped to the level of charging a fee for road kill. Pennsylvania has given new meaning to the often used phrase, “You break it, you buy it.”

