High School Football
  •    
  • Class AAAA
  •    
  • Class AAA
  •    
  • Class AA
  •    
  • Class A

Hunter’s big buck takes a plunge

BUCKHANNON, W.Va. — Any hunter who has pursued a single buck for an extended period of time will agree there is great satisfaction when you finally  stand over him.  Grant Harsh is one of those hunters who puts in the boot leather and scouting needed to kill a truly remarkable buck. He’s killed a few over the years, but the one he claimed in 2014 stood out from most.

“He first appeared on trail camera in 2012 and he was a really good eight pointer,” Harsh said. “To be honest I would have shot him in 2012 if I had found him. He appeared again in 2013 and I never got a shot and then he was back this year and looked almost identical.  He looked like a really mature buck.”

Harsh, a forester by trade, has the advantage of getting to spend a lot of time in the woods. He’s able to monitor rutting activity better than most simply because his office is the deer’s living room.  He’s also been able to still find sizeable bucks in Randolph County.

“Randolph is a little bit of a sleeper sometimes, but as most people know it’s a big place with a lot of high mountains and remote areas that allows some of them to get a little age on them.” he said. “That’s the key to a big buck is to get some age on him.”

Harsh thought he had his big buck located. He was in his tree stand in the frigid cold the week before gun season opened.  Snow created near whiteout conditions and the wind could chill to the bone in the noreaster which rolled into the state during the week which proceeded Thanksgiving.  Harsh’s persistence paid off when the big buck showed himself late in the day. Harsh drew, released the arrow, and to his horror made a bad shot a little further back than he wanted.  The buck bolted and with daylight burning, Harsh made the decision to wait.

“It was a 20 yard broadside shot.  When he’s staring you down, I guess all that practice goes out the window,” he said. “I can’t explain why the shot was bad. It was a liver hit and he ran a long way.  That’s why I decided to back out and not push him.  I figured I’d let him go lay down and die somewhere.”

Harsh was back at his stand at the crack of dawn next morning and began to track. Even with the snow, it wasn’t an easy trail to follow.

“That’s when your guts are just in knots,” he said.

As Harsh followed the wounded buck’s trail he noticed on his topo map the deer had dropped 800 feet in elevation.  The trail went all the way to the bottom of the mountain to the edge of a good sized stream.

“I could see in the snow he had slid off the riverbank and I couldn’t figure out why he wasn’t laying there,” Harsh said. “There were bobcat tracks in the blood, so somebody else was looking for him.”

Harsh also found evidence of coyotes in the area as well.  But just as he was about to conclude a pack of critters may have robbed him of his prize buck, he glanced into the middle of the river and spotted something unusual jutting up between two rocks.  There, between those rocks were the deer’s antlers protruding up above the crack between the two rocks.

“Man I tell you that’s a wave of relief,” he said. “You don’t know that you’re going to get that buck and then there he is and he’s yours.  It’s really rewarding.”

Trouble was, Harsh had come equipped to track a deer, not trout fish. He used electrical tape and a set of gaiters to modify and extend his Muck boots higher up his legs. He waded into the swift water to retrieve his prize.

“He was frozen solid and the river water was pretty cold too,” he said. “The gutting and skinning wasn’t the easiest, but it was worth it.”

Fortunately for Harsh there was a road which accessed the area not far from the spot he found the buck.

“At least I didn’t have to drag him back up that 800 feet of elevation,” he said. “If I had to do that, I’d probably still be there.”

Ironically Harsh killed a sizable buck last year along the same stream, but a couple of miles away.   His three year quest came to an end and it turned out to be the second largest buck he’d ever killed with a bow.  The buck weighed 155 pounds field dressed and based on his teeth was 4 and a half to five years old.  Harsh green scored the deer’s rack at 129 1/2 Pope and Young and it carried a 17 inch spread between the antlers.

“I guess all things happen for a reason.  I didn’t get him in 2012 or ’13. This year his luck ran out,” Harsh said. “It’s about being persistent if you find one and keep faith you’re going to eventually run into him.”

“





More Outdoors

Outdoors
Logan native has an awesome trip back home to start archery season
Logan native comes home to unlock the secrets of a buck which nearly died of EHD and thanks to an online video gained near celebrity status with a viral video
November 13, 2026 - 3:48 pm
Outdoors
Youth season produces an almost perfect 50-50 harvest
Youth hunters kill 1,383 antlered and 1,381 antlerless deer during the first season of the split youth hunting season
November 9, 2026 - 9:40 am
Outdoors
Teen Luke Stewart wins the BASS Nation State Championship
The senior at Clay County High School bested a crowded field which included some of West Virginias best bass fishermen.
November 8, 2026 - 2:37 pm
News
Bailey's resignation leaves a third vacancy on Natural Resources Commission
The seven member commission is down to four members as the final meeting of the year is scheduled for November
October 30, 2026 - 11:55 am


Your Comments