WASHINGTON, D.C. — Several members of West Virginia’s Congressional delegation are calling on Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin to “simply say no” to the federal Environmental Protection Agency when it comes to compliance with new carbon emissions limits in the proposed Clean Power Plan.

“Even though the rule is not final, that doesn’t mean that he has to adopt it. Let’s have the governor come out and say, ‘No,'” said 1st District Congressman David McKinley (R-W.Va.).
McKinley, 2nd District Congressman Alex Mooney (R-W.Va.) and 3rd District Congressman Evan Jenkins (R-W.Va.) recently sent a letter to Tomblin urging him to skip the submission of a West Virginia plan for the EPA’s new carbon rules.
“The Clean Power Plan,” the three wrote, “will undeniably force the state to change the way it produces electricity, reduce the amount of electricity used by West Virginia consumers, threaten grid reliability, and increase electricity prices on all West Virginians.”
Their claim is the EPA is trying to get states to do more than the agency would be allowed to do on its own.
“By declining to submit a plan, you will give the courts the necessary time to rule on whether the EPA’s proposed rule is legal while giving Congress a chance to address its concerns with the plan,” the letter said.
The new limits in the proposed Clean Power Plan, scheduled to take effect later this year, would reduce carbon emissions from existing coal-fired power plants by 30 percent on average, compared with 2005 levels, before 2030.
Individual states will be charged with developing their own pathways to get to established emissions limits or targets that vary by state.
As of now, state plans or requests for yearlong extensions are due by mid-2016. A two-year extension to 2018 would be an option in cases of state cooperation.
On Tuesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia dismissed lawsuits challenging the Clean Power Plan from West Virginia, more than a dozen other states and Murray Energy. The Court found that legal action was premature because the new emissions limits have not yet been finalized.
McKinley said future legal challenges to the Clean Power Plan depend on Tomblin’s next move.
“If the governor voluntarily adopts the plan, then we have a problem filing an action in court, because they’re going to say, ‘The governor of West Virginia’s already adopted that plan,'” he argued on Wednesday’s MetroNews “Talkline.”
Earlier this year, Tomblin signed a law that gives the Legislature oversight for any compliance plan state officials develop.

