High School Football
Listen Now: Morning News

A big buck in gun country

BAILEYSVILLE, W.Va. – Since Wyoming County is one of the four southern West Virginia counties where deer hunters are limited to archery only, it doesn’t come as any great surprise to hear a hunter from there killed a big buck with a bow.  However, Ronnie Stiltner of Baileysville has a rather different story.  Back in October he killed what is expected to be a record book buck, but not in the fertile hollows of his native Wyoming County.  Ronnie killed his monster whitetail in Wayne County.

“My uncle owns property down there and grows a bunch of big gardens,” Stiltner explained. “I think that deer had everything he needed and stayed right there on the farm.”

Wayne County has its share of trophy whitetails.  The non-typical record was killed there with a gun in 1997.  But the biggest bucks in West Virginia are generally thought to inhabit those four bow hunting counties where pressure is lighter and they live to a much older age.

“I had killed a couple of decent deer in there, but nothing equal to what this buck is now,” Stiltner said.  “I couldn’t believe it.  I didn’t think there was deer that size down there in gun country.”

Stiltner first saw the buck in 2011, the first time he started using a trail camera. Even then, he was a stud according to Stiltner.   He managed to get pictures of the buck every year and watched the progression.

“In 2011 he was a 12 point double main beam buck. In 2012 he was a 10 point. Then in ’13 he went back to a 12,” he said. “He just slowly progressed and grew every year.”

Stiltner first saw the buck in the flesh last fall.  The first sighting was at 100 yards and well out of range. During the second encounter the buck came within bow range, but it had become too dark to take a chance on a shot.  Stiltner let him walk. This year, the decision was rewarded.

On October 10th, Stiltner got to his stand around 3 p.m.  He worried because he had carelessly left a lot of scent around the area as he moved in.  He feared that would definitely work against him. It was an overcast day and for the first couple of hours, there were no deer at all.

“I was sitting there and I heard something very faint to my left and I looked and saw a big body about 30 yards away. Then he stepped out and I saw horns,” he said. “When he went behind a tree, I pulled back and when he stepped into the opening, I hit my release and I got him.”

The shot seemed perfect, but the buck wheeled and took off over the hill away from the stand.  There was plenty of self-doubt for Stiltner as he watched the massive animal flee into the brush, but in a few moments he heard the telltale sound of the crash down the mountain.  He spent a half hour sitting in his stand collecting his thoughts and emotions.  As daylight evaporated into the evening, Stiltner found the monster buck about 60 yards down the mountainside piled up against a rock.

“He was a main frame 10 pointer with a few kickers,” he shared.

Stiltner did not have the buck’s rack measured for a green score, but believed it could land in the top five of bucks killed in West Virginia.

“I think he’s in the mid-180’s,” he said. “I’ve had several people who have scored deer before tell me that’s about where they think he will fall.”

The rack will reach the 60 day drying period required for official certification under the Pope and Young scoring rules next week and one never knows for sure until the tape measure is pulled out. Chad Scyphers’ McDowell County buck from last hunting season officially scored 188 7/8 typical.  Time will tell if that record will be eclipsed only a year later.  However, whether it’s a record or not, all would agree it’s still one heck of a buck.





More Outdoors

News
Youth season opens this weekend with an opportunity for youngsters to kill a buck
For the first time since the youth deer season was created, youth hunters in West Virginia will be able to kill one buck in addition to the one antlerless deer each day of the season
October 14, 2026 - 2:45 pm
News
Morgantown deer hunt into its 16th year, venison donations top 8 tons
There are 94 certified hunters this year.
October 12, 2026 - 4:32 pm
Outdoors
Boone County hunter finally bags an elusive 10-pointer
Bill Browning had some serious history with a buck he finally took down in 2026
October 11, 2026 - 6:55 am
Outdoors
Boone County hunter kills the trifecta in eight days
Hunters get three months to chase critters in archery season, but Allan McCormick finished up his hunting in just over a week
October 8, 2026 - 3:14 pm