High School Football
  •    
  • Class AAAA
  •    
  • Class AAA
  •    
  • Class AA
  •    
  • Class A
10:06am: MetroNews Talkline

HS football highlights: Williamstown rallies to hand Buffalo first loss

Highlights above are by Jack Withrow, WVMetroNews.com

BUFFALO, W.Va. — Williamstown sophomore backup quarterback Carter Haynes helped lead the Yellowjackets on two late touchdown drives to beat No. 4 Buffalo 39-34 on the road. With starting senior quarterback Trenton Tallman on crutches to start the second half, the Yellowjackets (5-2) saw what was a 27-13 second quarter lead turn into a 34-27 fourth quarter deficit.

The two teams were tied 27-27 at the break.

“I think the difference was our defense,” said Williamstown coach Terry Smith. “(Tallman) went down right at the end of the second quarter and he was doing a super job, as usual, but he got hurt with a hip pointer.

More: Complete MetroNews high school football statewide scoreboard

“Our guys kind of hung their heads,” he continued. “But we said that we couldn’t just turn our stuff in at halftime – they played their butts off and I’m just real proud of them.”

Tallman had a 59 yard touchdown run, 93 yard kickoff return for a score and another one yard touchdown run prior to leaving the game.

A 13-yard touchdown pass from Haynes to Darren Hastings tightened Buffalo’s lead to 34-33, but the extra point failed. The Yellowjackets later scored the game-winning touchdown with under two minutes remaining on a nine yard run.

It was a critical win for Williamstown, which entered Friday night at No. 15 in Class A with a 4-2 record, coming off of a 14-point loss to rival St. Marys last week.

“I’m really happy for our seniors,” Smith said. “St. Marys played really well and we couldn’t really do much against them – they played terrific and my hat is off to them. I wasn’t really sure how we would react, but we had a good week of practice. I thought we were ready to go, but when (Tallman) got hurt, our guys just were determined to win the game.”

Buffalo dropped to 5-1 with the loss.





More High School Sports

High School Sports
MetroNews Top Plays (Week 11)
November 9, 2026 - 2:42 pm
High School Sports
First group of Bill Hanlin Award winners honored as WVSSAC football playoffs begin
November 8, 2026 - 10:30 pm
High School Sports
Photo gallery: John Marshall defeats Wheeling Park, 21-14
November 8, 2026 - 10:35 am
High School Sports
Greenbrier East ends East Fairmont's 68-game winning streak, takes Class AAA crown, 1-0
Ava Workman's gaol in the 42nd minute allowed GEHS to take their first girls soccer state title.
November 7, 2026 - 4:13 pm