High School Football

Man accused of killing Berkeley Springs 15 year-old to appear in court Wednesday

BERKELEY SPRINGS, W.Va. — The man accused of murdering a 15 year-old girl in May is scheduled to have a preliminary hearing Wednesday in Morgan County Magistrate Court.

Andy McCauley Jr, 41, waived the right to his original preliminary hearing, scheduled for May 24.

Andy McCauley

McCauley was taken into custody by state police on May 16 hours after the body of 15-year-old Riley Crossman of Berkeley Springs was found. Crossman had been missing since the early morning hours of May 8.

Officers from the Division of Natural Resources, assisting with the community-wide search, found Crossman’s decomposed body on an embankment near the 5500 block of Tuscarora Pike in Berkeley County, about five miles from Interstate 81.

A criminal complaint detailed the process that led investigators to charge McCauley with the crime.

Riley Crossman

Authorities used cadaver dogs to pick up the scent of a body in McCauley’s work truck. They also spotted drywall mud in the pickup truck bed, which matched drywall found on Crossman’s body.

Magistrate Kermit Ambrose will preside over the case, which is scheduled for 2 Wednesday afternoon in Morgan County Magistrate Court.

Authorities have not released Crossman’s cause of death.





More

Marshall Sports
Whirlwind of an ending sees Marshall top James Madison, 1-0
The Dukes had a late go-ahead goal waved off and the Thundering Herd immediately countered with one of its own to knock off the Sun Belt Conference leader.
October 22, 2026 - 12:50 am
Commentary
A Reasonable Fix for College Sports
October 22, 2026 - 12:12 am
Sports
Pozos scores twice, Mountaineers top Central Florida 3-0 to remain unbeaten at home
With his mother in town from Spain, WVU senior Pablo Pozos scored separate goals in less than 2 minutes to stake the Mountaineers to a 2-0 lead. That was plenty of support for goalkeeper Toby Mawer, who had six saves in a clean sheet.
October 22, 2026 - 12:01 am
News
West Virginia tourism district law affecting long delayed hotel project gets a state Supreme Court hearing
Justices on the state Supreme Court considered arguments over whether the statute improperly strips local regulatory authority and voting power to benefit a single private luxury hotel project.
October 21, 2026 - 5:36 pm