The appointment of a new member of West Virginia’s House of Delegates hinges on who sent what letter.
On deadline to defend the appointment against allegations that it deviated from local guidance, lawyers for the state are putting the specifics of a letter sent to the governor under a microscope. The argument gets down to details like how the signature is presented and what political group the letterhead represents. Notably, there’s been almost no discussion of what the letter actually says.
Gov. Jim Justice and the West Virginia Republican Party are at odds with the Wayne County Republican Executive Committee over the appointment to fill a vacant seat right before the start of the next legislative session.
The appointment was already high-profile because it’s to select a replacement for Derrick Evans, the newly-elected lawmaker who swarmed into the U.S. Capitol with a mob Jan. 6. Evans faces federal charges and resigned the seat.
After Evans resigned from the Legislature Jan. 9, the process to replace him began.
State code says any such vacancy is to be filled by the governor “from a list of three legally qualified persons submitted by the party executive committee.”
The law continues to say, “In the case of a member of the House of Delegates, the list shall be submitted by the party executive committee of the delegate district in which the vacating member resided at the time of his or her election or appointment.”
The Wayne County Republican Executive Committee on Jan. 13 submitted a letter citing state code that “executive committee members residing in the 19th Delegate District are submitting the following names for consideration” — Mark Ross, Chad Shaffer and Jay Marcum.
After the letter was sent, the Governor’s Office and the state Republican Party intervened.
That resulted in a second list produced Jan. 22 with the participation of the state party’s interim chairman, Roman Stauffer. That letter included two candidates from the first, Mark Ross and Chad Shaffer. But the second letter subbed in Joshua Booth for Jay Marcum.
Last week, the governor named Booth, a Kenova businessman, to fill the vacant House seat.
A lawsuit filed on behalf of the Wayne County Republican Committee chairman, Jeff Maynard, contends the governor and the state party overstepped their authority.
Responses to that claim were due today.
The response for the Governor’s Office was submitted by lawyers for the state Attorney General’s Office. The lawyers for the state contend the wrong local political committee submitted the initial letter, rendering it invalid.
“A district committee is statutorily empowered to provide the list of candidates to fill a House of Delegates vacancy, but a county executive committee is not,” wrote lawyers for the state.
The argument gets into the specifics of the initial letter, highlighting Maynard’s signature line that identifies him as chairman of the Wayne County Republican Committee. The letter’s heading also is from “The Wayne County Republican Executive Committee.”
House District 19 is located wholly within Wayne County. Part of the county lies outside the district, though.
So the lawyers from the state are saying the letter should have come from a political committee specifically representing the district.
“The relevant geographic entity is the Republican Party 19th Delegate District Executive Committee, not the Wayne County Executive Committee,” they wrote.
The state Republican Party makes a similar case in a separate brief.
“Petitioner’s only argument is that the Governor must choose a nominee from the County Letter because West Virginia Code § 3–10–5 ‘vests’ the right to submit such nominations in Petitioner as ‘Chair’ of a ‘county’ executive committee since the vacancy is for a district solely contained within his county.
“It does not. Nothing in the plain text of West Virginia Code § 3–10–5 authorizes a ‘chair’ or even a ‘county ‘executive committee to fill legislative vacancies.”

Brian Abraham, the chief of staff for Gov. Jim Justice, made a similar argument during a Friday appearance on MetroNews’ “Talkline.”
“We received the first list from the executive committee from Wayne County,” Abraham said. “Important to point out, it was from the executive committee, not the delegate committee that is supposed to be appointed, or elected, actually, to hear vacancies in delegate races.
“So we got this list and we were immediately contacted by the Republican state party, and we were advised that the Wayne County executive committee had not followed the party’s bylaws, had not followed the party’s procedures for replacing Delegate Evans.”
Brian Abraham, General Counsel and Chief of Staff for Governor Justice, speaks with @HoppyKercheval about the dispute over the appointment to fill a vacancy in the House of Delegates. WATCH: https://t.co/wkudfIRZCB pic.twitter.com/BaGWlhDJB9
— MetroNews (@WVMetroNews) January 29, 2021
But what goes unsaid in the state’s argument is the text of the letter that specifies “the executive committee members of Wayne County, WV, residing in the 19th Delegate District” submits the following names for your consideration.”
John Bryan, counsel for the Wayne County GOP chairman, said the lawyers for the state are confused.
“I’ll note that the response accuses us of misreading the statute,” Bryan wrote in a blog post about the case.
“In reality, they misunderstand the differences between multi-county delegate districts and delegate districts contained wholly within a single county. Where a district resides wholly inside one county, it is the county executive committee which presides over those committee members from that county in calling a meeting and voting on new candidates to provide to the Governor.”
In instances where there is no standing district committee, the state party’s bylaws say one would be appointed and then “facilitated” and finally certified by the county chairman, county secretary and state chairman.
That’s how Roman Stauffer, the state party’s interim chairman, wound up signing the letter with the second list. The second list also includes the signature of county chairman Jeff Maynard, an oddity that lawyers note since Maynard is now suing over the process.
Stauffer was campaign manager for Justice’s re-election effort last fall. He became the interim chairman for the West Virginia GOP earlier this month following the sudden resignation of Melody Potter on Jan. 11. Stauffer announced last month that he wants to pursue the chairman’s role for the long-term.
The lawyers for the state say there’s no reversing the governor’s decision because it’s too late. They contend the governor fulfilled his duties, and the 15-day window for choosing a new delegate has expired.
“Now nothing remains to be done,” the lawyers wrote, “but for the newly-appointed delegate to assume his rightly-appointed seat in the House of Delegates.”

