Listen Now: Morning News

Speakers quickly make their cases for and against West Virginia abortion bill

A big and passionate crowd of people participated in a public hearing about abortion policies under consideration for West Virginia.

Addison Gardner

One of the speakers was 12-year-old Addison Gardner of Buffalo Middle School.

“My education is very important to me and I plan on doing great things in life. If a man decides that I’m an object and does unspeakable and tragic things to me, am I, a child, supposed to birth and carry another child? Am I to put my body through the physical trauma of pregnancy? Am I to suffer the mental implications, a child who had no say in what was being done with my body?

“Some here say they are pro life. What about my life? Does my life not matter to you?”

Dozens of speakers at the House of Delegates chamber at first generally alternated between asking for a bill with major restrictions on abortion or asking for such a bill to be voted down or made more open. After a while, most of the speakers expressed views in favor of abortion rights.

Philip Dunn

“I believe that life is precious from the tomb to the womb,” said Philip Dunn, a Charleston pastor who sang a version of “Jesus Loves the Little Children.” “I believe that we need to understand all life is precious.”

The next speaker agreed that life is precious, but also said life is not always so clear.

Margaret Chapman Pomponio

“I’m pro birth. I’m pro abortion. I’m pro baby. I’m for bodily autonomy, and I’m for motherhood, fatherhood and parenthood,” said Margaret Chapman Pomponio, executive director of West Virginia Free.

“These terms and labels aren’t mutually exclusive and they are only as complex as we are — we as compassionate West Virginians, who understand that life is full of nuances, gray areas, beautiful ironies, mistakes and complications. This abortion ban deals in absolutes and denies our humanity and our humanness.”

People were given 45 seconds to speak. Many rushed through their prepared remarks, and most wound up being cut short. Some were escorted out after refusing to stop.

A rally in support of abortion rights was planned to follow the public hearing.

West Virginia lawmakers this week took their first steps toward consideration of abortion policy after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned landmark Roe vs. Wade guarantees and left laws to the states.

About noon today, delegates are to consider amendments and passage. After that, the state Senate will begin considering the same policy questions.

House Bill 302 encompasses a range of abortion policies, eliminating any period after conception for a choice to end pregnancy. In recent years, West Virginia law had allowed abortion up to 22 weeks of gestation.

The bill maintains criminal penalties of three to 10 years of incarceration for medical providers who perform abortions — the main provision of a law from the 1800s that had been inactive while Roe was observed — but specifies that the pregnant woman would not be charged.

The bill allows exceptions for a nonmedically viable fetus, an ectopic pregnancy, which is when a fertilized egg implants and grows outside the main cavity of the uterus, or a medical emergency, which is defined as a condition that requires an immediate abortion to avert the patient’s death or to avoid serious risk of damage to a major bodily function.

A medical emergency does not, in the bill, include psychological or emotional conditions.

The bill specifies several things that are not considered an abortion: a miscarriage, a stillbirth, use of established cell lines derived from aborted human embryos, treatment by a licensed medical provider that accidentally terminates or severely injures the fetus and in vitro fertilization.

The bill also specifies that it does not prevent the use of contraceptives.

Missy Ciccarello

“My body, my choice is a lie and the right to bodily autonomy because scientists and embryologists agree that  at conception a separate whole human being begins, where life begins,” said Missy Ciccarello, leader of the Kanawha County chapter of West Virginians for Life.

“We would not be gathered under the dome of our state Capitol to determine the radical role of an act that killed nothing. We wouldn’t be here.”

Katie Quinonez

Following her was Katie Quinonez, executive director of the Women’s Health Center of West Virginia. Quinonez continued her remarks after being told her time was expired.

Her microphone was cut off and a camera cut away, but a crowd in the gallery cheered after she then concluded. The crowd was told to refrain. Quinonez was one of several speakers to be escorted out following their time at the podium.

Before that, she said, “Let’s be clear. This ban has nothing to do with life. It has nothing to do with health. It has nothing to do with family. It’s about control. This abortion ban is, at its core, a decision deeply rooted in sexism and racism about the role women and people who can become pregnant play in society.”

More News

Lawyers in suit over foster care system blast state and say lost email evidence is an emerging trend
In both instances, wrote plaintiffs in the foster care case, 'West Virginia agencies similarly failed to preserve the email accounts of employees who had left the agency.'
November 28, 2023 - 7:57 am
Early winter snow squall causes travel problems in and around Morgantown
A number of wrecks reported Tuesday morning. WVU cancels early morning in-person classes.
November 28, 2023 - 7:44 am
MetroNews This Morning 11-28-23
Get up-to-date on what's going on around the state.
November 28, 2023 - 6:23 am
Today is 'Giving Tuesday' for the American Red Cross
November 28, 2023 - 2:45 am