High School Football
  •    
  • Class AAAA
  •    
  • Class AAA
  •    
  • Class AA
  •    
  • Class A
2026 General Election Coverage   Watch |  Listen

Governor and chief of staff want to block deposition in lawsuit over jail conditions

Gov. Jim Justice and his chief of staff are asking to steer clear of giving sworn evidence in a class action lawsuit about conditions in West Virginia’s corrections system.

Jim Justice

Lawyers for Justice and his administration’s chief of staff, Brian Abraham, filed a motion in federal court this week to quash subpoenas that would require depositions by the two.

The motion filed by Charleston attorney Michael Hissam on behalf of Justice and Abraham contends the two are not parties in the lawsuit. The filing also contends that they have no information that would provide value beyond what others in the case could present.

“Absent truly extraordinary circumstances, the Governor and his Chief of Staff, as nonparties and high-ranking state government officials should not be subject to a deposition seeking information that is — at best — tangential to the claims involved in this litigation and is readily available from other sources,” Hissam wrote in the filing in U.S. District Court for the U.S. District of West Virginia.

The lawsuit filed in September, 2022, is a class action against against Southern Regional Jail, the West Virginia Division of Corrections and every county commission that pays Southern Regional to house inmates.

Allegations in the suit include inmates sleeping on mats soaked in toilet water, some being forced to sleep on concrete floors, poor air quality because of black mold and denial of nutritious food, running water or a toilet. The most recent battle in federal court has been over whether state officials improperly disposed of records that could have been evidence in the case.

State figures named in the case include retired Homeland Security Secretary Jeff Sandy and Betsy Jividen, former commissioner of the Division of Corrections.

Brian Abraham

Justice and Abraham, received notices to be deposed in the case next week, Oct. 24.

Part of the information sought has to do with the administration’s decisions to cite $28 million in covid-related expenses to the corrections system, draw down that amount in federal CARES Act funding and then send $28 million to a gifts and grants fund controlled by the governor. Of that amount, $10 million eventually went toward funding Marshall University’s new baseball stadium.

Plaintiffs attorneys filed a motion this week, asking the judge to compel them to respond to questioning. The filing by the plaintiffs anticipated a motion on behalf of Justice and Abraham to quash the subpoenas.

“Both deponents have been identified by the Defendants in this case as having knowledge relevant to the issues alleged by the Plaintiffs. Specifically, Defendants such as Jeff Sandy, testified that for years his department requested of the Governor’s office funding to address pervasive overcrowding, pervasive understaffing, and over two hundred million dollars in deferred maintenance,” the plaintiffs lawyers wrote.

The filing for Justice and Abraham contends the Governor’s Office has already cooperated through in-house attorneys who participated in meetings and calls. The filing also states that responsive emails from the governor’s and chief of staff’s accounts have been turned over. And it indicates, “Neither the Governor nor the Chief of Staff possess a state-issued cell phone.”

The motion to quash the subpoenas maintains that the governor and chief of staff are high-ranking state officials who would be distracted from their work if they had to testify regularly in court cases involving the state.

“The chilling effect on the deliberative process of a decision-maker is clear,” according to the filing for Justice and Abraham. “If a Governor or his Chief of Staff knows they can be called to testify regarding any decision tangentially related to any civil lawsuit, they will be far less likely to engage in a robust consideration of the available options or render difficult decisions.”





More News

News
Senators pay tribute to former Senator Jay Rockefeller, pass resolution honoring his life and service
Former West Virginia senator died earlier this month at the age of 89.
November 17, 2026 - 5:56 pm
News
A day after indictment of West Virginia auditor, more scrutiny comes to light
Governor urges Hunt's impeachment to be considered and refers inquiry about Hunt's used car lot to feds. Lawyer oversight board confirms open complaint about Hunt.
November 17, 2026 - 4:28 pm
News
Man arrested in Marshall County on charges that he killed 10-year-old boy in Cleveland last year
Khalif Muhammed has been wanted for months.
November 17, 2026 - 4:14 pm
News
Man in custody after Wheeling bank robbery
November 17, 2026 - 2:32 pm