GLENVILLE, W.Va. — A father and son in Gilmer County will never forget the opening weekend of the 2023 archery hunting season in the Mountain State.
Scott Dobbins and his son Triston, age 13, had their eyes on a buck. However, despite pictures of the whitetail from various trail cam angles, it turned out to be a far more impressive buck in person than either expected.
“We actually hunted this deer last year. As a matter of fact, in the first part of November, I ended up grunting this deer in last year and just as I let go he took a step and I just clipped his hind quarters. It put a pretty good scar on his ham. That made him pretty easy to identify, but we just couldn’t get another shot at him,” explained Scott in a recent appearance on West Virginia Outdoors.
The two spent a long day in the blind on the first day of the season. They were entertained by a series of does and a flock of turkeys who descended on their position and hung around much of the day. By the evening after those critters had wandered off and an eight point buck came into view.
“That 8 point came and got me all excited because I thought it was him,” explained Triston.
As cool as the eight-pointer was, he wasn’t the buck Triston had committed himself to holding out for and the big eight walked away. However, Triston explained he would return soon–and he wasn’t alone.
“That eight point came back and as I was watching it, I saw a rack come up over the hill. He just appeared standing there and I looked at Dad and said, ‘There he is.’ and started shaking a little.”
The massive buck wandered in and out of their territory, but never presented himself for a shot, at least not on that day. Triston explained the knew the buck was more of a noctural creature and doubted he would be back there in the morning hours. So Sunday afternoon the pair slipped back into the blind and set up for an evening hunt.
Triston was playing with his phone, when things suddenly got way more interesting.
“I just happened to look up and he was right there looking straight at the blind. I told Dad, ‘There’s a buck, there’s a buck!’ Dad looked around the tree and said, ‘That’s him.'” he said.
With the adrenalin now pumping full force through his veins, the 13-year old steadied his crossbow in preparation for a shot. Scott told him to be patient and calm, but that was easier said than done.
“He started to walk in, but he was playing the wind. He finally got up on this little hump and just stood there for five or ten minutes,” Triston explained.
The non-committal and overly cautious buck was testing Triston’s last nerve before he turned to walk away. He left Tristan with a less than optimal shot, but the moment of truth was upon him.
“He stopped and was quartering pretty hard. I aimed right at the back of his ribs so I could at least get one lung and I shot him right there,” Triston explained.
“From my angle in the blind it looked to me like he’d shot that deer in the extreme middle or paunch area. Little did I know it was textbook,” Scott said
Scott was running the video camera. After the shot, the two exited the blind to listen. According to Triston his dad still wasn’t sold on the lethal capability of his accuracy. It turned out the big buck ran about 70 yards and keeled over dead. They followed a very small blood trail with minimal sign. The search was so difficult, Scott considered backing out and returning the next day with a deer blood trail dog, but realized soon after that consideration it wouldn’t be necessary.
“Dad just happened to walk out a point and found a little blood, then a little more, and dad peaked around the tree and said, ‘What’s that?’ I looked and said, ‘That’s him, and he’s dead!'” said Triston.
When they finally laid hands on the buck, neither could say much.
“I was at a bigger loss for words than what he was,” Scott offered.
The big buck had a 10 point mainframe, but carried 15 scoreable points with a lot of mass and extension on each of his tines. It was a quality buck for any hunt, but Scott was particularly impressed the buck came from Gilmer County. The buck still had strands of velvet hanging from the base of his massive rack.
News spread quickly and Triston became a local folk hero among his boys at Gilmer County Middle School on Monday.
“I walked in and I bet seven people escorted me to my seat and said, ‘I want to see a picture of that deer.'” he laughed. “I showed them the picture and they said, ‘Man that IS a big deer.'”

