Commitment, focus, and Dad’s love all factors in Mercer teen’s big buck

PRINCETON, W.Va. — MaKaylah Bishop,14, of Princeton is a freshman at Pikeview High School in Mercer County. However, in the world of hunters you could say she has achieved senior status.

On Veterans Day, MaKaylah brought down a 13 point buck in Mercer County which had been on her radar for more than a year.

MaKaylah Bishop

“Last year he was a bigger buck, but he had broken one side off fighting during the rut. I had been wanting to see him this year, but I hadn’t until one night when we were coon hunting and we saw him. He was still in velvet and I knew he was the biggest buck around here and I wanted to kill him ever since then,” she explained in an interview for West Virginia Outdoors.

“She could have killed him last year,” said her dad Daniel Bishop. “He was an 11-point last year, and she could have killed him in rifle season, but he had the one side broken off so she let him pass.”

MaKaylah set up a series of cameras across the 30 to 40 acres her family owns and hunts in Mercer County. She was getting pictures of him almost every day, especially early in the season, but it was impossible to predict the big bruiser’s movements.

“We just couldn’t lock him down to a certain point. We were trying to find out where he was bedding. She kept changing and moving cameras to try and figure out a pattern, but you couldn’t pattern this deer. I still to this day don’t know where he was bedding,” said Daniel.

MaKaylah was focused entirely on killing the big buck. She was in the stand whenever she had the opportunity and especially if the conditions were right. She was even late for school on a few frosty mornings after the rut started. She tried to be there in hopes the bruiser would come her way. She also passed on several other deer which most hunters would have been elated to tag.

“I passed up a 10-point my sister wants. I passed him up almost every morning. I also passed up a few nice eight-points. I passed them up every morning waiting for him,” said MaKaylah

“This 10-point she’s talking about, he’s probably around 140 to 145, he’s a good buck. She’s let him go numerous times in the mornings and the evenings and never even thought about shooting him,” Daniel explained.

It was this level of commitment which struck Daniel as he stood in the stand on a couple of occasions in the early part of the West Virginia’s archery season.

“The first week of bow season I could have killed him. She was in school and he came in a couple of times on me and I just couldn’t bring myself to shoot him. I had a couple of easy shots on him, but I knew how hard she had worked for him and I just couldn’t do it. I thought I could when I saw how big he was, but when I thought about her, I knew I just can’t do this,” said the proud girl dad.

He was concerned however his sacrifice may have been for naught. The buck went completely nocturnal and seemed to disappear in October.

“We hunted all of October and I was thinking he might have gotten away from both of us,” laughed Daniel.

But then came Veterans Day, Saturday, November 11th. Makaylah was in her perch and Daniel was in his stand five-feet below her in the same tree. Out of the direction they expected the big deer to come, it all fell into place.

It isn’t often a hunter kills a buck where the inside spread of the antlers is wider than their shoulders

“He was chasing a doe and he did come from the way I expected him to, but Dad had to grunt to get him to stop,” said MaKaylah.

“He came in quick and I finally got him to stop at about 38-yards. She was shook up, but she took a deep breath and made it happen,” said Daniel.

The bolt of MaKaylah’s crossbow pierced both of the big buck’s lungs and he disappeared over the hill. MaKaylah had a hard time following Dad’s advice to give the buck time to die. They waited an hour before they started the track, but he hadn’t gone far and suddenly MaKaylah had her petite hands wrapped around those massive antlers.

“He was way bigger than I thought he was. The pictures didn’t do him justice,” she said. “It was exciting. He’s definitely the biggest buck I’ve killed. He’ll be a lifetime buck for sure.”

Maybe, but then again maybe not. MaKaylah is 14, she’s got a LOT of living and hunting left to do.





More Outdoors

Outdoors
Youth season produces an almost perfect 50-50 harvest
Youth hunters kill 1,383 antlered and 1,381 antlerless deer during the first season of the split youth hunting season
November 9, 2026 - 9:40 am
Outdoors
Teen Luke Stewart wins the BASS Nation State Championship
The senior at Clay County High School bested a crowded field which included some of West Virginias best bass fishermen.
November 8, 2026 - 2:37 pm
Outdoors
Bailey's resignation leaves a third vacancy on Natural Resources Commission
The seven member commission is down to four members as the final meeting of the year is scheduled for November
October 30, 2026 - 11:55 am
Outdoors
When his wife agreed to allow a hunt on their anniversary, an Upshur County hunter made it count
Kyler Doss had his eye on a big buck earlier in the archery season--and managed to talk his wife into allowing him to hunt on their anniversary. The request paid off.
October 28, 2026 - 1:33 pm