MULLENS, W.Va. –– Sportsmen in West Virginia are growing increasingly concerned about otter numbers in the Mountain State and the impact they are having on some fish populations. However, it’s still unclear if the negative impact many sportsmen have claimed is real or perceived.
During last week’s Natural Resources Commission meeting at Twin Falls State Park in Wyoming County, at least two speakers during the public portion of the event raised anecdotal concerns.
Graduate student, Laurel Glover, releases an otter on the Greenbrier River in Pocahontas County after surgery to apply a GPS transmitter to monitor movement as part of ongoing research. VIDEO: WVDNR
“The number of otters is too high. They have decimated our waters,” said Don Cook of Wyoming County who is the President of the Big Branch Hunting Club and a past President of the Baileysville Sportsmen. “Some call them trash fish, but there’s no carp, no suckers, and no shad. They used to be plentiful in the Guyandotte River, but they’re not there now. I attribute that to the otters. We’ve seen them in trout streams and they’re everywhere. I see them, other sportsmen see them, and that problem needs to be rectified sooner rather than later.”
Fishing Guide Roy Blankenship who runs fishing trips on the New River shared equal concern.
“We’re seeing them two or three times a week where in the past you might have seen one a month. They’ve become pretty thick on the New River. I was fishing from Sandstone to Meadow Creek and we had one roll up with a 14-inch smallmouth in its mouth. He took about four or five bites and it was gone and he was back under the water to hunt for another one,” Blankenship explained.
Although some sportsmen want to slow down the otter growth, the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources is calling for patience. Biologists are trying to get a better handle on just how many there really are along the state’s streams. Holly Morris, Furbearer and Small Game Biologist for the DNR, gave a thorough presentation to the meeting. Currently there three key studies underway by researchers at Frostburg State University and West Virginia University to learn more about the state’s otter population.
The Frostburg study is examining stomach contents of otters and worked to determine the size and species of fish in their stomachs. The research is almost done. A similar study at WVU folded DNA of those fish into the research. Morris said worries from trout fishermen the critters are chasing stock trucks doesn’t appear to be happening.
“That’s not the case. Based on the DNA diet study, she found primary diet items are crayfish and fish in the sunfish family. Trout only comprised about 10 percent of the frequency of contents found in the stomach,” said Morris.
Otters are a native species to West Virginia. They were trapped out in the 1950’s. As habitat and water quality improved, the DNR was able to join several other states and reintroduced otters in the 1980’s and 1990’s. Since then, they’ve moved and multiplied. Just how much they’ve multiplied isn’t clear.

Although some sportsmen noted to the Commissioners they had seen as many as five and six otters travelling and feeding together in a stream, that didn’t alarm Morris.
“Keep in mind, these are a lot like bears in how they operate. They live in family groups so it could be a female with this year’s offspring, so it’s not that alarming to see five at one time, that’s just what they do,” she explained.
Another research progress placed GPS trackers on otters for 30 days to track their movement. It was quite a revelation.
“It blew my mind,” said Morris. “I had no idea how far they were travelling and how fast, but it does explain the difficulty of trapping them and keeping up with them,”
Male otters in the mountain counties moved 30 miles and some moved as much as 15 miles in a day within a watershed. Morris said the research showed said they were largely moving and looking for food, but would also move frequently during breeding season looking for a mate as well. Lowland otters on the bigger rivers weren’t as mobile, but they also weren’t home bodies either.
“They’re not moving nearly as much. There we saw males moving up to 10 miles. That’s very different from the mountains, but there’s a few reasons to consider for that. The bigger bodies of water may support more food sources and they may have a bigger density for otters. In a nutshell with otters, they don’t move very far unless they have to,” she explained.
But the frequency of movement could also mean sportsmen who believed they had seen multiple otters, may have been seeing the same otter on multiple occasions in different places.
Although some sportsmen have asked Commissioners to increase the bag limit to trap otters, Morris said they will not be able to do that until the research is complete. It’s expected those recommendations, whatever they turn out to be, won’t be ready until the end of 2025.
“We need the survival data from the current project to determine if otters are doing fine or are they few and far between and they’re dying of other diseases and causes that we don’t know about yet. As soon as we get the survival data, we’ll have a better idea of what we can stand as population when it comes to harvest,” she explained.

But last year, trappers in West Virginia captured fewer than 100 of the creatures. Steve McCue, Vice President of the West Virginia Trappers Association said they’re typically not worth it to most trapping enthusiasts.
“Like Holly said in her presentation, it takes about 30 trap nights to catch an otter. With the price of gas, running 30 nights to a trap to catch an animal that’s only worth about $35 isn’t really economical,” said McCue.
Some Commissioners also questioned whether raising the limit, which is currently one a year, would make a difference.
Both Commissioners Jeff Bowers and Greg Burnette suggested raising the limit from one to five wouldn’t make any difference if nobody is going to target them.
Still, Morris remained cautious toward tampering with the limit. She said it’s impossible to know what the price of fur could do and if it make a sharp increases, it was important to consider than when setting the limit. She also noted otters, are a “CITES” species and regulated by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Along with bobcats, regulations for otters need to be carefully handled by the sate.
“We don’t have the statistical information we need. Right now it would be just picking a number and hoping it’s good. Annually the DNR vouches to the federal government that yes, we’re managing the species correctly and everything is based on sound science. That’s why we need to wait until these studies are complete,” she said. “We put a lot of time, money, and effort into bringing the otter back and we don’t want to go backward,”

