BUFFALO, W.Va. — A year ago Brett Walker of Buffalo managed to irritate both his boss and his wife with his persistent need to go hunting. But a Pope and Young Buck had claimed the area of Poca River in Putnam County where he hunted. He couldn’t contain himself until he was finally able to bring that buck home.
It was quite an accomplishment, and Brett figured his chances of doing that a second time were fairly slim. However, he had captured a single picture of another trophy deer in the exact same area and was holding onto hope he might get some déjà vu for 2024.
“I’ve noticed whenever there aren’t very many yearling bucks showing up, there’s usually a good sized deer in the area that’s keeping them run out,” Walker said in a conversation on West Virginia Outdoors.

Walker has a single trail cam picture of the buck to prove it existed, but he wasn’t consistent and he had not demonstrated any kind of an early pattern. Walker, who is a construction laborer, was working out of town and at home had a foreign exchange student, a daughter, and a pregnant wife. Going into late October, he knew his opportunities to hunt the buck were going to be limited.
“I have six stands I hunt out of and I let the wind dictate where I’m going to go. I talked to my job foreman and told him when we got home, I wanted to take a couple of days right around the rut,” he explained.
This year his boss was far more forgiving and even offered, “…deer hunting is a legitimate excuse to miss work.”
Walker’s wife asked what he’d like for his birthday, and it was a simple answer, he wanted about four straight days in the woods in late October or early November after the first cold front. She was agreeable. Walker had his time mapped out and the first cold front hit on Thursday October 30. So he hunted Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and his fourth sit was a cool Sunday morning.
“I sat down about daylight, then about 8:30 to 8:45 a doe came running off the hill toward me and went about six yards in front of me. I heard a real loud grunt and I knew there was a buck behind her,” he explained.
Brett stood up, and prepared himself for the shot amid some incredibly thick cover. His three shooting lanes would require quick action because they were narrow. He was able to see the buck coming with a rack wider than his shoulders.
“He stopped right before the shooting lane and when he took off again, I let out a grunt, which I basically screamed at him. He stopped and looked up and I had about a seven yard shot. I was able to get him right behind the shoulder,” Brett continued.
The shot was lethal. The buck travelled only about 15 yards and fell over. But a testament to just how thick the cover was in the area, Walker didn’t see him fall.
He was elated to finally put hands on his second Pope and Young Buck in as many seasons from the exact same hollow along Poca River.
“I may never see another deer that big in my life. But of course, if I’m blessed enough to do it a third time, I’ll probably say that again next year,” he laughed.

