CRAIGSVILLE, W.Va. — A Nicholas County hunter proved the Monongahela National Forest is not a dead zone for trophy bucks. Hunter Short lives in Craigsville, but grew up in Webster County. He still returns there every season to hunt land he has been on since he was a young boy learning to hunt form his dad and grandad.
“I’ve hunted in that general area for years. It’s a place that really means something to me,” he said.
Over the course of time, private property he previously had permission to hunt has been lost to lease agreements. So Hunter has spent more time hunting in recent years in the nearby National Forest. The country is rugged and big and it’s possible there are bucks there you’ll never know about.
“It’s a lot more of a challenge. I know there’s deer up there that die of old age that never see a person and people never see them,” he said.
Listen to “Hunter Short on WV Outdoors 11-16-2024 Big Webster County Buck” on Spreaker.
It was during one of those public land sits he encountered one of those kinds of bucks.
“I heard him, but I couldn’t see him. Then I heard raking in the leaves and I still couldn’t see him. I thought, ‘Man, there’s a deer in here,” he said.
Finally he caught sight of a tail flicker. He watched the deer’s body, but still couldn’t see its head. The head was hidden behind a tree until he put his nose to the ground and Hunter could see the tips of tines sticking out the other side of tree.
“I said, dang that’s a buck,” he laughed.

Hunter jumped to his feet, situated his bow, and pulled back as the big buck looked back toward him. Hunter explained he let the arrow fly and hit a little further back than he had hoped, but it was on target.
He came down from his tree. He took his climber stand back to his truck and made a couple of phone calls. He did about all he could to kill time before the anxiety of waiting got the best of him.
“I waited about an hour, but I thought man I got to go looking for him. I started following a blood trail and he was bleeding pretty good. He only ran about 75 to 100 yards around the hill and he was dead there,” explained Hunter. “I walked up on him and saw the 7 points one one side with the split brow and I said, ‘OH MY GOSH! I knew he was a shooter, but I didn’t know he was as big as he was until I walked up on him.”
It was also a buck Hunter had never seen, either in person or on camera, until the day he killed him.
“I didn’t even know he was in the area. I had pictures of a few smaller ones, but nothing like that,” he said.

