CHARLESTON, W.Va. –The official size of a large number of whitetail deer killed in West Virginia through the years has been quietly determined inside a small room at the Charleston Coliseum and Convention Center in late January.
Certified and trained scorers from the Boone and Crocket and Pope and Young Clubs will again be silently stretching a measuring tape and cyphering figures on a laptop to come up with an official score for dozens of bucks. Hunters annually bring those deer to the West Virginia Hunting and Fishing Show to be scored.
“We’ll typically do more than 100, but last year we had one slow day because of the weather and we were south of 100, but we do quite a few of them,” said West Virginia Division of Natural Resources Biologist Trevor Moore who heads up the scoring team for the agency.
Most of those which will be scored this weekend in Charleston are kills from the 2024 archery season. Those killed during the firearms season probably haven’t had adequate time to dry to meet the scoring qualifications.

“They have to have been dried 60 days otherwise it’s a ‘green score’ and it’s not official. We get so busy that we don’t want to waste time on a green score, so we don’t do them,” he explained.
Moore added however, it doesn’t have to be a recently killed buck.
“Killed in 1960? Bring it in and get scored, it doesn’t just have to be from this last hunting season,” he explained.
Those who want a buck scored but haven’t had the adequate time to dry can consult with Moore at the show about arranging a time to meet up with a staff member to get the scoring done at a later date once the drying time requirement is complete. Meanwhile, hunters can drop off the antlers in the room, which stays secure and quiet throughout the weekend.
“They can watch if they want to, but the only thing we ask is that they remain quiet. We have all of these teams doing the scoring and everybody needs to communicate with each other. Being a hunter myself I know how tempting it is to tell a good story and talk about these awesome trophies, but we ask that the public try to refrain from that when we’re trying to determine a score,” Moore added.
The scoring will be done by three teams consisting of two people. Both members of each team are certified to do the scoring, but one will do the actual measurements and the other will handle data entry and the math to come up with the official score.
Scoring is in two categories, typical and non-typical. The goal of a typical score is to reward symmetry and mass of the rack. Any deviation from those two will cost the rack scoring potential with deductions. However, non-typical antlers are actually rewarded for the difference in the two sides. Moore explained they try to help a hunter make the right decision about which way they want the buck scored.
“They can decide which way they want it, sometimes people want to score a typical deer as non-typical because the number may go up, but when compared to other non-typicals all of their numbers are higher too and if you don’t have non-typical points, you’re going to be at the bottom of the barrel. We always try to tell the hunters, this is where it looks the best,” he said.
The scoring times for the weekend:
Friday January 24 3 p.m. to 8 p.m.
Saturday January 25 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Sunday January 26 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

