“Am I wrong?”
It’s a question I ask myself more and more since I took over the co-hosting duties of Metronews Talkline a few months ago. Each day, as I prepare to discuss topics and interview guests, I sift through information on various subjects and often encounter something I was not aware of.
The exercise can be exhausting. I slow down, examine the information, the source, and try to determine if it is presented objectively or if it is a subjective viewpoint trying to sway my opinion. Even subjects that I believed I had a strong handle on, I wondered if I was getting it all wrong.
For example, when it comes to the vaccine exemptions in West Virginia, I have always believed current state law is based in sound reasoning and supported by scientific data. However, after listening to compelling testimony from witnesses during committee hearings in the House of Delegates this past legislative session, I questioned my belief and went back to the research.
As it turns out, after looking through more data and soliciting opinions from medical professionals, my stance remained unchanged. However, questioning my previous position did open my mind to consider other perspectives rather than dismiss individuals with whom I disagree.
Reflecting on an issue is not an indication of self-doubt. It’s quite the opposite.
It demonstrates maturity and curiosity and helps us to make better decisions. If a previously held position withstands scrutiny it can become a strongly held belief. Intellectual flexibility, a willingness to change our minds when met with new data, can be a strength.
When applying this principle an issue such as the current vaccine exemption debate, it opens the door for constructive dialogue and the possibility of devising a policy that meets public health needs and addresses parents’ concerns.
My role as co-host of Talkline requires me to constantly question what I think I know about a wide range of topics, even deeply held beliefs. That way we can have a dialogue about matters that are important to you.
Am I wrong?