High School Football

DoHS says federal audit of CPS snapshot of the past not a reflection of the present

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — The state DoHS and cabinet secretary Alex Mayer responded Monday night to MetroNews concerning a federal audit that highlights a failure to complete required paperwork when abuse and neglect cases are reported.

Alex Mayer

A long statement from Mayer and the agency said the audit from the Office of Inspector General at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services should be viewed as “a snapshot of the past, not a reflection of the system in place today.”

The agency said its reforms started to be made before the audit report came out.

“They reflect proactive leadership and a recognition that improvements were needed, long before federal auditors confirmed those concerns,” the agency said.

The audit report, posted Friday, said auditors reviewed 100 reports of child abuse and neglect and only nine complied with all requirements.

“On the basis of our sample results, we estimated that 21,621 of the 23,759 (91 percent) screened-in family reports for our audit period were not in compliance with 1 or more requirements related to the intake, screening, assessment, and investigation of child abuse and neglect,” the audit concluded.

The OIG said it decided to do the audit after the 2024 death of Boone County teenager Kyneddi Miller in which reporting was questioned.

The full statement from DoHS:

“The recent OIG audit identifies deficiencies that occurred during the review period October 2023- September 2024, but it does not reflect the significant reforms and modernization efforts already underway within the West Virginia Department of Human Services (DoHS) since the Morrisey Administration took over in 2025. Since assuming office, Governor Patrick Morrisey and DoHS leadership have launched an aggressive transformation of the child welfare system, one that addresses the very issues highlighted in the report and, in many cases, goes well beyond federal expectations.

“In July, Governor Morrisey announced that the State is now fully complying with CAPTA’s public-disclosure requirements for child fatalities and near fatalities, marking a decisive shift from years of limited transparency. This openness directly responds to OIG concerns about documentation, oversight, and accountability. As part of the Department’s commitment to transparency and meaningful engagement, DoHS conducted a statewide Child Welfare Listening Tour earlier this year in communities across every region of West Virginia. Families, foster parents, providers, educators, court partners, law enforcement, and frontline staff participated, offering candid feedback about system barriers, communication challenges, and opportunities for improvement. That feedback is now guiding policy revisions, workforce supports, and practice-model development. 

“The Department also modernized its operational infrastructure to strengthen accuracy and decision-making. The Child Welfare Dashboard is being rebuilt to make data clearer and more actionable. Supervisors are now required to conduct monthly case reviews, supported by state office quality-assurance teams. Additionally, the new Leadership Education and Development (LEAD) initiative ensures supervisors receive consistent, high-quality training.

“DoHS established a Critical Incident Review Team to conduct deeper, more consistent analyses of serious incidents. The introduction of the Comprehensive Practice Model is one of the most critical reforms underway and directly confronts the core deficiencies identified in the OIG report. Many of the audit’s findings, ranging from inconsistent screening decisions and incomplete assessments to variability in safety planning and documentation, stem from the absence of a unified, statewide practice framework. The practice model fills in those gaps by establishing clear, evidence-based expectations for every stage of child welfare work: how referrals are screened, how safety is assessed, how decisions are documented, how families are engaged, and how ongoing casework is conducted. By anchoring frontline practices in a common set of tools, protocols, and values, the model ensures workers have the structure needed to make accurate, timely, and sound decisions.

“Intake processes have also been strengthened. Caseworkers now gather more comprehensive information beyond the initial referral, improving assessment accuracy and reducing the likelihood of decisions based on incomplete data. This reform mirrors national best practice and directly corrects one of the OIG’s core findings.

“It’s important to point out these reforms were launched before the OIG report was released. They reflect proactive leadership and a recognition that improvements were needed, long before federal auditors confirmed those concerns. For this reason, the OIG report should be seen as a snapshot of the past, not a reflection of the system in place today.”

The OIG did commend the state for changes it’s made.





More News

News
Delegate plans legislation to restrict teacher-student communication in wake of sexual misconduct arrests
Del. Tristan Leavitt, R-Kanawha, says he's concerned about a lack of safeguards in West Virginia on the matter.
November 15, 2026 - 6:50 pm
News
Justices say it's too late to seat an elected delegate accused of threatening lawmakers
West Virginia Supreme Court justices heard arguments in September about whether state officials followed proper procedures when they vacated the seat of a delegate who had been arrested and then replaced him.
November 15, 2026 - 5:12 pm
News
New West Virginia First Foundation partnership looks to find gaps, improve operations with new higher education input
Partnership announced recently among foundation, six higher education institutions.
November 15, 2026 - 3:55 pm
News
Officials say Kessel Fire is 90% contained, cleanup and investigation continues into new week
November 15, 2026 - 2:51 pm