
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — The sixth and final defendant in the January 2014 chemical spill which left 300,000 households without water for up to 10 days has settled allegations over his involvement. Former Freedom Industries President Gary Southern entered a guilty plea to three charges in Charleston federal court Wednesday.
“I think we’ve now come to the point where we’ve prosecuted everybody we’ve found to be criminally culpable in this case,” said United States Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia Booth Goodwin.
Southern admitted to one count of negligent discharge of a pollutant, one count of unlawful discharge of refuse material, and one count of negligent violation of a permit condition. A storage tank on the Freedom Industries site along Elk River in Charleston developed a hole from years of corrosion. The leak allowed as much as 10,000 gallons of the coal cleaning chemical MCHM and a secondary chemical PPH to flow into the Elk River. The material was drawn into the West Virginia American Water Company’s Kanawha Valley treatment plant only a mile downstream and tainted the water supply for a nine county region.
“Did you do it?” Judge Thomas Johnston asked of Southern during his plea hearing in U.S. District Court.
“Yes your honor,” was Southern’s reply.
The three counts would require at least some jail time for the former executive. Southern faces 30 days to three years in federal prison and fines up to $300,000. The jail time was important to the government’s agreement to a plea settlement.
“Executives are used to writing checks for things,” said Goodwin. “They’re not used to checking their three piece suit for a jail house jumpsuit.”
However, also as part of Southern’s plea bargain, federal prosecutors dismissed 12 additional counts for which Southern was indicted, including a number of charges related to attempting to hide personal assets from bankruptcy proceedings. Under the stipulation of his plea, the government’s pursuit of a forfeiture of Southern’s personal wealth will be dropped.
“What we’ve agreed to do is give it back in a trust should there be a mechanism to draw that into the various tribunals that are looking at that very issue,” said Goodwin.
Civil litigation over the matter is pending. Under the trust, Southern’s assets would be held by his own attorney until those cases are over. Goodwin said the trust insures the location of the money or other holdings will be known should it have to be drawn upon as restitution to those lawsuits. But it’s still unclear how much, if any restitution Freedom Industries, Southern, or any of the other five defendants would owe to victims of the water crises.
Southern is a native of Great Britain. It would be up to the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service to determine if deportation proceedings are warranted according to Goodwin. He said his office doesn’t typically get involved in citizenship affairs.
“I think we are sending a clear and powerful message about the importance of keeping our water supply safe and the consequences of jeopardizing it,” Goodwin said. “If you intentionally or even negligently allow the release of a pollutant into our water supplies, it’s not about writing the check, it’s about trading a a three piece suit for a prison jumpsuit.”
Southern’s sentencing is set for December 16th. He remains free on his original $10,000 bond until the sentencing.

