CHARLESTON, W.Va. — More than five years after her brother was killed with 28 other coal miners at the Upper Big Branch Mine in Raleigh County, Dr. Judy Jones Petersen heard the words she had been waiting to hear someone say of former Massey Energy CEO Don Blankenship.

“I didn’t put any weight on the charges, I just wanted someone to step forward and say, ‘He is guilty. He is guilty,'” Petersen said Thursday after a 12-member jury returned a split verdict following deliberations over parts of ten days in Blankenship’s trial.
Blankenship was found guilty of a misdemeanor conspiracy charge for violations of mandatory mine safety regulations prior to the UBB Disaster, but was acquitted of two counts of making false statements to securities officials and lying to shareholders after the explosion.
“They did say ‘guilty’ so he’s not walking away from this,'” agreed Shirley Whitt whose brother Boone Payne died at UBB. “Even though it’s a misdemeanor, at least we know that he was guilty of conspiracy.”
Petersen, Whitt and Whitt’s sister, Sherry Keeney Depoy, attended the trial daily along with other family members of the men who died in the massive explosion on April 5, 2010 and those family members waited through ten days of jury deliberations before the verdict was returned Thursday.
Whitt said she was “somewhat relieved” as U.S. District Judge Irene Berger started to read the verdict “that he would not just get to walk away with nothing.” “But when they said ‘not guilty’ on the other two, it was kind of like someone just hit you in the stomach,” she continued.
For Depoy, the verdict was a disappointment.
“It was just a misdemeanor and we all know better than that. We know he’s guilty of more than a misdemeanor.” Her question for the jury: “Were you in the same courtroom that we were in? Were you, really, and heard what we heard? Of course, in all fairness, we knew more than they knew.”
There were tears from the family members prior to the reading of the verdict Thursday.

“I did think about my brother, Edward Dean Jones, and he is vindicated today,” Petersen said. “Even though Mr. Blankenship may not be convicted of all of these crimes, he is guilty, my friends.”
Sentencing for Blankenship is tentatively scheduled for March 23.
Depoy has a message for Berger: “Give him the maximum and that will really be closure for us.”
“I don’t look for it to be much,” Whitt said of the possible penalty for Blankenship who faces up to a year in prison. “I do hope that, come that day, that we’ll be able to move on — when he’s sentenced.”

