The West Virginia High School Football Playoffs have a problem.
In an effort to create a level playing field for schools that have a wide range of student enrollments, the current classification and playoff system is inadvertently highlighting the competitive imbalance that administrators wanted to avoid.
The WVSSAC Board of Control, which is composed of principals from all member schools, has been grappling with the evolving public school landscape and its impact on secondary sports. Student enrollment numbers have decreased by 46,000 students over the last decade and all 55 counties have experienced declines.
The Board of Control has attempted to maintain competitive balance among schools that range in enrollment from 1,776 students at Morgantown High School to as few as eight at Pickens. The goal is straightforward: ensure schools of similar size compete against one another.
But the changes have produced an unintended consequence: increasingly noncompetitive postseason games that put players and coaches on both sidelines in undesirable situations.
The problem is most apparent in Class AAAA, where just 20 of the state’s largest schools are classified, yet 16 qualify for the playoffs. In last week’s first-round games, the top eight seeds went 8-0, winning by an average margin of 41.7 points.
Since the current system was introduced in 2024, first-round playoff games have become increasingly lopsided. The average margin of victory in 2024 was 31.25 points. That figure has climbed to almost 42 points a game. Over the last three years the top four seeds won by a combined score of 688-85.
The current playoff format isn’t fair to the teams at either end of the bracket.
For teams near the bottom, the opportunity to compete in the playoffs against a superior opponent is hardly a reward. The players who have persevered through a disappointing season should not have to endure an extra game that’s conclusion is all but predetermined.
Meanwhile, coaches of top-seeded teams enter those first-round games with their fingers crossed. They’re not necessarily worried about the outcome. They’re anxious about whether their players will emerge healthy, without injuries that could derail a potential championship run.
School-sponsored athletics are an extension of the classroom. They teach valuable, lifelong lessons about teamwork, determination, competition and adversity. Sports also give young men and women the opportunity to experience disappointment, even heartbreak, and learn how to overcome it.
But it’s difficult to make the case that much is being taught or learned in a lopsided, 50-point drubbing.
The effort to maintain competitive balance and encourage more participation in West Virginia high school athletics is admirable. But when it comes to football, the scales are out of balance.
The playoffs should be a reward for a successful regular season and give student-athletes a goal to strive for. They should showcase the state’s best athletes and programs and provide meaningful competition on the road to a championship.
Instead, the current system is shining a spotlight on the very competitive disparities it was designed to eliminate.

