MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — Circuit court judges from Braxton, Randolph and Harrison Counties will hear the first motions in a suit to remove 4 Morgantown council members from office.
The panel, requested in the suit from city resident and business owner George Papandreas, meets at 9 a.m. Friday in Monongalia County Circuit Court.
Papandreas’ suit was filed in October alleging the four, who were re-elected to their positions earlier this year, “are guilty of misconduct, malfeasance in office, incompetence and neglect of duty.”
Council members Bill Kawecki, Jenny Selin, Nancy Ganz and Mayor Marti Shamberger were all re-elected amid accusations stemming from ward and boundary changes described as self-serving to keep two council members from running against one another for office and for breaking campaign rules.
“This is something that is over a lot of old issues, issues that have already been settled by other forums. Usually you pull a three-judge panel together only for very serious offenses not for minor matters or political differences,” Jenny Selin said the day before the hearing on WAJR’s Morgantown AM.
Councilmen Jay Redmond, Ron Bane and Wes Nugent all signed the petition seeking the court’s review.
“I don’t believe the laws have ever been fully executed in that regard. The Secretary of State is pursuing someone in Charleston, a former delegate, over issues that are crazy. You have a mayor here in Monongalia County who was pursued pretty vigorously. This is not small potatoes when it comes down to it being written in black and white,” Nugent responded.
The rift comes at a time when council has taken up budget concerns and voted to implement the city’s first user fee to help fund the police department and streets department. Council members on both sides of the suit do agree the distraction is not good for city business.
“There are weightier issues I’d like to for us to be focused on. But, this is at the heart of what is good government. That’s an important question. We know there are controversies everywhere. And, a lot of this is underpinned by trust,” Nugent added.
Selin maintained allegations of misconduct and city charter violations are frivolous. “We need to make sure we’re taking care of the city not spending time in between a two year election cycle to sue each other. That is not what Morgantown has stood for in the past. I’m hoping this will be the end of it.”
State Supreme Court Chief Justice Margaret Workman decided the suit warranted a hearing.
Braxton County Circuit Judge Richard Facemire, Randolph County Circuit Judge David Wilmoth, and Harrison County Circuit Judge John Lewis Marks are expected to receive motions for dismissal from the attorney representing the four council members.
A follow-up January hearing is predicted to be scheduled.

