MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — A three-judge panel plans to hear witness testimony in a civil case to remove four Morgantown city council members from office.
Circuit Court Judges Richard Facemire, David Wilmoth and John Lewis Marks rejected a motion for dismissal from the attorney representing Bill Kawecki, Nancy Ganz, Jenny Selin and Marti Shamberger Friday morning.
“A removal proceeding under W.Va. code 6-6-7 cannot be based on an act that occurred in a prior term of office. That’s still the law in West Virginia,” said Lonnie Simmons.
In a suit filed by business owner George Papandreas, the four are accused of misconduct, malfeasance in office, incompetence and neglect of duty.
The roots of the complaints can be traced back to council’s decision in 2014 to ignore the Ward and Boundry Commission’s recommendations for adjusting ward boundry lines within the city. The non-partisan commission’s proposal would have combined the fourth and seventh wards. That would have forced Selin and Ganz to run against each other in the upcoming municipal election.
Council instead developed and approved its own proposal that kept Selin and Ganz in seperate wards. Ganz, Selin, Kawecki and Shamberger all voted in favor of the new proposal while Wes Nugent, Ron Bane and Mike Fike opposed it.
“This 1975 case contemplates considering things that happened prior to the election which is what we have here,” said Papandreas’ attorney Mark Kepple.
Other accusations include violating election rules.
Harrison County Circuit Court Judge Marks, who led Friday’s hearing in Monongalia County Circuit Court, said petitioners should be able to state their cases.
The panel took up three other motions before setting deadlines in the case.
“We’re going to order you to meet,” he said.
Attorneys have until January 8 to exchange exhibits and witness lists and summaries of their testimony.
They must also submit written stipulations on the facts on which both parties agree.
The case will resume in a January 22 hearing.

