High School Football
Listen Now: MetroNews Midday

Convicted Preston murderer asks for new judge in appeal

KINGWOOD, W.Va. — A hearing for convicted murderer Richard Knotts ended quickly Wednesday after his attorney said they will ask for a new judge.

Knotts, 58, is serving life in prison without the chance of parole. A Preston County jury convicted him of first-degree murder without mercy in 1990 for the killing of Robert Barlow Jr.

Knotts is appealing his conviction based on DNA evidence.

Preston Circuit Judge Steve Shaffer told the attorneys he attended either elementary or junior high with the victim and the victim’s father used to cut his firewood. After consulting with his client, defense attorney Jeremy Cooper said they would file a motion to disqualify Shaffer from the case.

No new hearing date has been set.

Story by Kathy Plum





More News

News
Charges in Oak Hill after fatal shooting
18-year-old charged in death.
November 4, 2026 - 12:03 pm
News
MetroNews This Morning 11-4-26
West Virginia news, sports, and weather for Wednesday, November 4, 2026
November 4, 2026 - 6:58 am
Election Coverage
Democrats double their seats in House of Delegates, although GOP will maintain supermajority
Right now, the House of Delegates has 9 Democrats and 91 Republicans.
November 3, 2026 - 11:15 pm
Election Coverage
Democrats pick up seats in West Virginia Senate, which will still have GOP supermajority
Right now the state Senate has 32 Republicans  and two Democrats. 
November 3, 2026 - 10:28 pm