High School Football

Charleston attorney looking at 11 other deaths at Clarksburg VA Medical Center

CLARKSBURG, W.Va. — An attorney for the families of veterans who were murdered at the Clarksburg VA Medical Center said Monday 11 additional deaths are being reviewed for possible connections to convicted murderer Reta Mays.

Tony O’Dell

Charleston attorney Tony O’Dell said during an appearance on MetroNews “Talkline” some of the deaths date back as far as 2015.

“We have 11 other cases that an untoward event happened at the hospital, we don’t have the smoking gun glucose readings, but these people looked like they were going to be discharged. They were definitely doing better and had been moved out of ICU to the step-down floor,” O’Dell said.

Mays, 46, of Harrison County, a former nursing assistant at the hospital, pleaded guilty in July in connection with seven deaths. She faces consecutive life terms for the murders and another 20 years for a count of assault with attempt to murder. A sentencing hearing hasn’t yet been set. A status hearing in the case is scheduled for Oct. 30. She killed them by giving them insulin they didn’t need. She hasn’t yet said why. 

O’Dell said he’s still waiting for the Veterans Administration to provide him “complete and full sets” of medical records for the families of the additional veterans.

O’Dell recently filed a civil lawsuit in connection with the April 2017 death of Air Force veteran Charles Dean. O’Dell said Dean was hospitalized at the Clarksburg VA Medical Center because of dehydration but was getting close to discharge when he crossed paths with Mays.

Reta Mays

“This was a fella that was completely independent, able to do whatever he needed to do, had all his mental faculties. They’re making progress to discharge him and all of the sudden Reta Mays has him that night and all of the sudden he’s dead,” O’Dell said.

MORE  Tentative settlements reached in VA death cases 

Separate court hearings are scheduled for Nov. 20 in Clarksburg Federal Court in connection with tentative financial settlement agreements with the federal government on six previous wrongful death cases. O’Dell said the government has promised to provide him Mays’ work schedule as part of the settlement agreement on the civil cases. He said that should help him piece together more information about the other deaths.

“Just knowing that she was the person caring for them when the unexpected, untoward event happened to them is huge evidence in these cases,” O’Dell said. “They want answers. They want to know. It’s not just these families that deserve answers but all of the veterans that depend on that medical center deserve answers.”

O’Dell and others are also waiting on the investigative report from the Office of Inspector General in the Clarksburg VA case. The OIG investigation began in July 2018.





More News

News
Huntington Man Convicted of Second-Degree Murder in Fatal 2025 Seventh Avenue Shooting
A Cabell County jury has found 23-year-old Amar Abdu Richardson guilty of second-degree murder and firearms violations following a fatal shooting last year on Seventh Avenue in Huntington.
October 30, 2026 - 5:22 pm
News
One killed, four injured in Buckhannon crash
Crash happened Thursday afternoon.
October 30, 2026 - 3:45 pm
News
Capito stands on her record for reelection Tuesday
Senator said she knows what West Virginia wants and believes she's helped increase the state's standing in Washington D.C.
October 30, 2026 - 12:51 pm
News
Former correctional officer sentenced to prison for role in conspiracy punishing inmates
Michael Pack, 40, will spend two years in prison.
October 30, 2026 - 12:26 pm