Justice names civil defense attorney, former federal prosecutor to Supreme Court

The appointee to be West Virginia’s newest Supreme Court justice is Haley Bunn, a lawyer with Steptoe & Johnson who grew up in a Wyoming County coal mining family.

Gov. Jim Justice made the announcement today, moving to fill the court vacancy that resulted from the departure of Evan Jenkins. Bunn would serve the remainder of an unexpired term until the seat is up for election in 2024.

“I really have been feeling a call-back to public service and serving the people of West Virginia,” Bunn said today on MetroNews’ “Talkline.” “And I’m excited and honored to have the opportunity to do so in this capacity.”

Bunn said already today that she plans to run for the seat when it is on the ballot. “I plan to seek election and hope that these couple of years on the bench will prove I’m the right person for the job,” she said.

Haley Bunn

In addition to her current civil defense work, Bunn has been a federal prosecutor in West Virginia’s southern district. During her federal service, she prosecuted a series of public corruption cases in Mingo County that drew national attention and resulted in the convictions of four elected officials.

In 2017, the United States Department of Justice selected her as one of 12 prosecutors in the country to serve in a newly created Opioid Fraud and Abuse Detection Unit, where she took a leading role in combating the state’s opioid crisis.

She is a graduate of West Virginia University and the West Virginia University College of Law.

“I’m committed to the rule of law above all,” Bunn said today.

Bunn was one of nine applicants for the vacant Supreme Court seat.

The others included Charleston attorney Nicole Cofer, who formerly worked for state Attorney General; Lewisburg attorney Robert Frank; Cabell Circuit Judge Gregory Howard; attorney Charles Lorensen, who was chief of staff for former Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin;  Kristina Raynes, an assistant prosecutor in Putnam County; James Rowe, a retired circuit judge and former state lawmaker; former Putnam County Prosecutor Mark Sorsaia; and Kanawha Circuit Judge Joanna Tabit.

“Haley will be a strong conservative voice on the court,” Justice stated today. “She understands the importance of faith, traditional values, and law and order. Those things are the backbone of West Virginia. And she knows that for our economy to continue growing, employers and job creators have to be confident they can get a fair shake in our courts.

“She’ll apply the law fairly and impartially, and she’ll be a Supreme Court Justice that all West Virginians will be proud of.”

The Supreme Court seat opened after the Feb. 4 announcement by Justice Evan Jenkins that he would resign to return to the private sector.

Jenkins was named to the court on Oct. 1, 2018, to temporarily replace Justice Robin Davis, who stepped down after a legislative inquiry into the entire court. Jenkins was elected to the seat in November, 2018, for a term that ends in 2024.

After that announcement, Governor Justice said the Judicial Vacancy Advisory Commission would immediately begin the process of filling the vacancy with an appointee to serve on the court until the people of West Virginia elect a new justice.

Originally, the appointment would have lasted until next fall’s General Election, when Supreme Court candidates would have been on the ballot to serve for the remainder of the term.

But lawmakers passed a bill during the most recent legislative session to say the governor’s appointment would stand if the unexpired term is no more than three years. The bill applies to a range of judicial vacancies ranging from the local level to West Virginia’s highest court.

So had  the bill not passed, the appointee or whoever would have won the 2022 special election conceivably could have been on the ballot twice in short order.

West Virginia’s current Supreme Court includes Chief Justice John Hutchison and justices Beth Walker, Tim Armstead and Bill Wooton. Judge Alan Moats has been sitting by temporary assignment in the seat previously held by Jenkins.

Hutchison and Armstead originally began serving on the Supreme Court through appointments by Justice, although each has since won election.

Bunn comes from a multigenerational family of West Virginia coal miners: two of her great-grandfathers, both her grandfathers, her father, and many other family members have been underground coal miners, and her husband’s family operated coal mines in West Virginia for decades.

“Haley Bunn is a wonderful West Virginia story,” Justice stated in an announcement of Bunn’s appointment. “She’s a coal miner’s daughter and a daughter of southern West Virginia who’s committed her life to serving her state and her community.

“She’s from Wyoming County, where the opioid epidemic hit as hard as it has anywhere in America, and she decided to devote much of her career to fighting that epidemic. Haley’s also a seasoned courtroom veteran whose experience as an elite litigator will be invaluable on our Supreme Court of Appeals.”

More News

Remembering West Virginian Melvin Forbes: a legend in modern hunting rifles
The late Morgantown native created the world's most accurate and dependable lightweight hunting rifle, which nobody since has been able to truly copy
June 15, 2024 - 9:44 am
Some alleged campaign violations being turned over to county prosecutors
State Election Commission initially reviewed the cases.
June 15, 2024 - 9:22 am
Shooting impacts Elkins Police Department
Sheriff’s department expresses condolences.
June 15, 2024 - 12:47 am
Multiple victims in Princeton shooting
One alleged shooter hospitalized, second in custody.
June 14, 2024 - 10:08 pm