RODERFIELD, W.Va. — Most archery hunters who chase bucks in the southern West Virginia coalfield counties do so from a tree stand. Typically once they settle onto a particular buck, they’ll play a game of cat and mouse for days moving stands and trying to anticipate the buck’s next crossing point to be in position for a shot. But Robby Newberry of Roderfield, West Virginia can actually claim he used the “spot and stalk” method on a giant McDowell County buck in November.
“I actually had a ton of pictures of him. I had pictures of him around half the days of the season, but he was always showing up right at the very edge of shooting light,” said Newberry in a conversation for West Virginia Outdoors.

Newberry had become familiar with the buck all the way back in 2021.
“He was a good deer even then, probably 140 to 145,” he explained.
During 2022, the buck ballooned into a giant with a massive spread on his race and tines even longer than his 2023 antlers. Newberry had been keeping a close eye on the deer and hoped to keep it to himself. That’s not always an easy thing to do in these parts.
“I knew there were some guys close by and I knew one for sure had a picture from the year before. I was a little concerned that I was going to get on Facebook and see him killed pretty much every time I got on,” he laughed.
He was able to roughly pattern the buck’s movements and was able to continue to get pictures of him through October, but he was hunting the weekends when he had off days and just held out hope they might cross paths. He finally got the chance November 11th.
“He came in down the hill from me and missed my camera. He went over the hill and got on a trail I didn’t know was there. He got in some brush and I had a small window. I probably shouldn’t have taken the shot, but I did and hit a limb and missed him,” Newberry explained.
Although it was a miss, he didn’t believe it had spooked the deer too much and felt confident he was still in the best position to kill the buck. Several days later Robby hunted the morning on one side of the hollow, then decided to switch sides and move to the next ridge where he had also captured pictures. He walked to the head of the hollow to his four-wheeler to have lunch and prepare for the long hike to the other side.
Terrain in this part of West Virginia is steep and as Robby walked one bench, he could hear a commotion just over the edge of the mountain on the next bench down, about 30 yards away.
“I peaked over the side and I could see him. He was pushing some does and hadn’t seen me, but he was about 40 yards front of me. I pulled back and took off about 50 yards and looked over again and he’s still about 40 yards ahead of me. I drew back and grunted. He stopped, but didn’t stay there long enough for me to take the shot and then disappeared around the point,” he said.

Robby knew the buck was headed to the other side, but he knew that trip to the other side on the higher bench he was walking would be a considerably shorter distance. He bolted through the dry leaves, almost certain the buck would hear him, but it was a chance he had to take.
“Yeah, it wasn’t quiet and I pretty much knew this deer was going to bust me, but he must have had those does on his mind because he never even noticed me,” said Robby.
Newberry stopped on the other side when he jumped two does and again feared it would be the fatal mistake. Turns out, he was in the perfect position.
“I scurried over there as quick as I could and he was coming right to me,” he said.
He settled the pin, loosed the arrow, and put the perfect shot right through the buck’s side and sent him crashing over the mountainside.
“He doesn’t look quite as big from the side, but when I shot him and he bounded over the hill and you could see the frame on him, I knew that was by far the biggest deer I’d ever seen,” he said.
Not too long afterward Robby was able to locate and put his hands on the biggest deer he’d ever seen and completed a nearly three year quest with an epic spot and stalk.

