High School Football

Day 3 of Nevera murder trial ends with longtime friend testifying that defendant admitted to killing

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — The third day of the murder trial for the Morgantown business owner accused of killing his ex-girlfriend ended with a longtime friend testifying that Joseph Nevera admitted to killing her and later showed him her body.

Joseph Nevera

Nevera, 52, of Morgantown, is charged with first-degree murder for the 2924 death of Osborne. He allegedly buried her body in a shallow grave.

Prosecution witness John Claburn, a friend of Nevera’s for over 20 years, testified he helped Navera move Osborne’s body off of Nevera’s property.

“I was definitely lying down (that night) because I hopped up, and I knew it was Joe, I said, ‘Joe, what’s up?’, (he said) ‘Open the door,’ he was loud, but it was not like he was drunk, I opened the door, and you could tell he was not right,” said Claburn. “He’s antsy, and he goes, ‘I killed her,’ I said ‘Joe, what are you talking about?’ he goes, ‘I killed her.'”

According to Claburn, Nevera knocked on the door of his trailer located on the campground owned by Nevera in a state of disturbed unrest the night Osborne was murdered. In a rushed manner, Nevera told his neighbor, who also worked on the grounds, completing handywork, that he had killed his ex-girlfriend and left her body inside the vehicle she was driving earlier that day. He later stated that he was asked to drive his Dodge Ram behind Nevera as he made efforts to bury her in a shallow grave. A choice he remembers with deep regret.

“He goes on, he goes like, ‘I watched the light go out of her eyes,’ and that’s when I knew (he did something horrible), I said, ‘Joe, what are you talking about? What do you mean?’ I walked down the porch, and he goes, ‘Look,'” said Claburn in his testimony. “And he opened the back door, and she was in the back seat, upside down.”

Claburn testified that Nevera took independent steps to eliminate any potential evidence that could link the two to the murder of Osborne and her burial. Among them were interactions that took place several weeks after Osborne was declared missing, where Nevera threw Claburn’s cell phone out of a moving car during one instance and patted down his longtime friend to see if he was wearing a wire during another. All signs that he felt reflected the guilt of the defendant.

“We left (a gas station one day), and as we pulled out of there, he goes, ‘You got your phone on?’ I said, “Yeah,” so we passed his mom’s and turned on to Glory Barn (Road), he goes, “Let me see it,” and I show my phone, and he chucks my phone out the window,” said Claburn. “I said, ‘Joe, what’s up?’ I said, ‘That phone doesn’t mean nothing to you,’ I felt like it was evidence (he was attempting to get rid of), I don’t know.”

Forensics experts also testified on Thursday that the remains found in the shallow grave about 2 miles away from Nevera’s property were confirmed with over 99.9 percent certainty to be the remains of Osborne. Board-certified forensic anthropologist Dr. Dennis Dirkmaat, who studied the signs of physical wounds that were found on Osborne’s skeletal remains, testified that wounds around the neck and nose reflected strong evidence of strangulation and facial wounds. Evidence showed that Osborne’s body had endured physical abuse before she was murdered, despite no official cause of death.

“So here we have broken, fractured bones in the nasal region as well as in the neck, in the cervical vertebrae,” said Dirkmaat.

Claburn is scheduled to be cross-examined Friday.

“I wish I had never met Joe Nevera, I wish I was never here in West Virginia, I mean, I wish a lot of things, and I did what I did,” said Claburn. “You can’t take that back, of course, I wish it didn’t happen, that it didn’t turn out (the way it did), I wish I was never involved in any of this.”





More News

News
New West Virginia First Foundation partnership looks to find gaps, improve operations with new higher education input
Partnership announced recently among foundation, six higher education institutions.
November 15, 2026 - 3:55 pm
News
Officials say Kessel Fire is 90% contained, cleanup and investigation continues into new week
November 15, 2026 - 2:51 pm
News
Teamsters Local 175 union proposes "pre-ratified" contract in attempt to settle dispute with The Beverage Market
49 workers at beer distribution company in Kanawha County have been on strike since May.
November 15, 2026 - 2:02 pm
News
City of Huntington expanding work to connect those experiencing homelessness find housing
City has received $600,000 in American Rescue Plan funding to build apartments for housing.
November 15, 2026 - 12:38 pm