MORGANTOWN, W.Va. –The Monongalia County jury that took about two-and-a-half hours to convict a Morgantown businessman of first degree murder has now denied him mercy.

The jury deliberated for about 90 minutes in Monongalia County Circuit Court on Wednesday before finding that Joseph Nevera, 52, of Morgantown, should serve life in person without the possibility of parole for killing his girlfriend Kimberly Osborne in May 2024.
Testimony included over a half dozen witnesses, with members of Osborne’s family speaking for the majority of the mercy phase.
“He should spend the rest of his life in prison,” said Elizabeth ‘Rose’ Osborne, the victim’s mother. “He showed my daughter no mercy, he showed my grandchildren no mercy.”
Osborne was last seen Mother’s Day weekend in 2024, and her body was found the following November in a shallow grave off Little Indian Creek Road by hunters. Family members of Osborne who testified described the violent relationship that occurred over a period of years, which was confirmed through bodycam footage of domestic violence incidents involving Nevera during the trial.
“I hope and pray that my grandchildren are young enough and resilient enough to have normal productive lives, but for me that’s never going to happen,” said Rose Osborne. “He may as well take him on life, and he knows that, he has to know that.”
The jury was also shown Nevera’s failure to follow parole requirements after he was arrested for his two domestic violence incidents. This was combined with testimony from people who lived with the couple during their relationship.
“She’ll never get to see me graduate high school, or see me leave middle school, she’s never gonna be able to do any of those things,” said Madison Lowther, Osborne’s daughter. “He doesn’t deserve to be out, he can’t do this to someone else’s family.”
Belinda Beavers, a longtime friend of Nevera, was the lone witness to testify on behalf of the defense during mercy proceedings. On the stand, she brought up years of examples of Nevera’s generosity, as well as support from members of his family during times of need.
“A big tree fell on my building, and my daughter’s new Mustang was in there, he just came right over, I mean, no questions, brought his chainsaw,” said Deavers. “He was just always there for me, if I called him, he would just come right away, just like if he would call me, I would go right away.”
Monongalia County Prosecutor Gabrielle Mucciola said the Osborne family has suffered enough.
“The children of Kimberly Osborne should have never had to place missing persons all over town, they were children,” said Mucciola. “Rose shouldn’t have had to search the ground for a grave and this defendant has shown no remorse, no mercy for the family of Kimberly Osborne.”

