High School Football
  •    
  • Class AAAA
  •    
  • Class AAA
  •    
  • Class AA
  •    
  • Class A
MetroNews Hotline   Watch |  Listen
5:06pm: MetroNews Sportsline

Grand jury hands down indictment on state Auditor Mark Hunt and associates

U.S. Attorney Moore Capito announced today that a federal grand jury indicted West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt, alleging he improperly issued tax deeds to steal properties for a longtime friend and business associate.

“I am innocent of these charges,” Hunt, a Republican elected as Auditor in 2024, said in a social media post. 

“This indictment is an insult to the principles on which this country was founded. An indictment is only an allegation. I am presumed innocent and I will vigorously defend myself against these charges. I remain focused on the work of the Auditor’s Office and will continue to serve the people of West Virginia while this matter is resolved in court.”

The Auditor investigates waste, fraud and abuse across state agencies and local governments.

Here, Hunt is accused of it.

Roger Hanshaw

The indictment prompted a swift condemnation from the speaker of the House of Delegates, who said Hunt should resign. Speaker Roger Hanshaw said the “serious allegations cast a long shadow over the Office of the State Auditor and its role of maintaining the integrity of other state and local officials.

“Every American is entitled to due process and the presumption of innocence in every criminal proceeding, but the public is entitled to leadership from the officers it elects; Mountaineers should always be free from the sort of taint these indictments create,” said Hanshaw, R-Clay.

“Auditor Hunt should immediately resign from his office. If he resolves to do otherwise, the House of Delegates will take swift action in January to restore integrity to the Office of the West Virginia State Auditor.”

Larry Pack

Another statewide officeholder, Treasurer Larry Pack, also said Hunt should resign. The two serve together as representatives on the state board of public works.

Pack, a Republican, posted that “these are grave charges that demand serious attention,” adding that West Virginians “deserve a government that is fully transparent, accountable and works for the betterment of our state. State Auditor Mark Hunt should resign immediately.”

The indictments allege that Hunt, 66, of Charleston, was helped in his scheme by three individuals also indicted by the grand jury:

  • David Keith Cole, 57, of Charleston, deputy chief of staff for the state auditor’s office and the office manager of Hunt’s private law firm;
  • Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, of Charleston, general counsel for the West Virginia State Auditor’s Office; and
  • Robert Lisle Johns, 66, of Charleston, the longtime friend and business associate, and special counsel at the state auditor’s office.

Each defendant was indicted on nine counts of theft of property and Caudill and Cole were each indicted on one count of making materially false statements to federal investigators.

The grand jury also indicted Hunt, Cole, and Marie Ann Hoffmann, an employee of the state auditor’s office, alleging Hoffmann committed bank fraud while aided and abetted by Hunt and Cole.

Those charges allege Hoffman, 66, of Hurricane, submitted falsified government timecards so they included hours she worked at Hunt’s private law firm. Hoffman was paid state wages for her work at the private law firm with Hunt’s knowledge and after Cole validated and approved her falsified government timecards, the indictments allege.

Moore Capito

“The rules governing public office are not optional. They do not change based on who you know, who your friends are, or what position you hold. The integrity of public institutions depends on public officials faithfully carrying out their responsibilities,” Capito said at a press conference.

“As alleged, the state auditor violated that trust. Folks in West Virginia have every right to expect the people entrusted with their tax dollars, and the public institutions follow that law. And when there is evidence that public officials have abused that trust, it is our responsibility to investigate, and we’re warranted to prosecute.”

Capito noted that those accused were not arrested and that they would self-report for further proceedings. The defendants next will make an initial appearance in federal court for arraignment.

“I don’t want to comment on the ongoing investigations, but you will hear from us if there are superseding indictments,” Capito said.

Johns is associated with a business entity that sought to purchase nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties. The West Virginia State Auditor’s Office oversees the process by which properties with delinquent taxes can be redeemed.

Federal prosecutors said multiple career employees within the State Auditor’s Land Division determined that all nine properties were legally ineligible for deed issuance because the purchaser had failed to make required payments and file required paperwork within the established statutory timeframes.

Over the objections of these career employees, the indictments allege, Hunt personally signed and issued deeds for eight of the properties on March 28, 2025, and a deed for the ninth property on June 6, 2025. Johns was hired as special counsel for the state auditor’s office, a full-time position, in June 2025.

The indictments allege Hunt was aided and abetted by Caudill and Cole in the creation and issuance of the nine deeds.

The indictments allege that as a result of the scheme, the defendants stole the nine properties from their lawful owners.

Mark Hunt

Hunt, a former state delegate and senator, has served as the state Auditor since 2025. He has practiced law for 30 years, initially as managing partner of Hunt & Serreno PLLC and later at Mark A. Hunt & Associates PLLC.

A federal grand jury is a group of citizens summoned by a U.S. District Court to hear evidence and decide whether there is enough to move forward with charges.

A grand jury does not decide if someone is guilty or innocent. They only decide if there is “probable cause” to believe a federal crime was committed.

Not every grand jury results in charges. And, in the step after that, not every set of charges results in conviction.

MetroNews reported late last month that the Auditor’s Office denied an information request for subpoenas issued to the office or its personnel, saying the release of the documents would compromise federal grand jury material. 

Speaking last week on MetroNews Talkline, Hunt said he was not certain whether his office has been under federal investigation. He acknowledged some sort of an inquiry, though.

Asked on Talkline last week to clarify whether the office is under investigation, Hunt responded, ” I don’t know. I mean, the the feds have asked for some documentation.

“You know, we have people in the office who handle those type of issues, I haven’t seen them, and I understand that the requests have have been marked with that. There’s boxes I think that they marked — it said it’s confidential, so, you know, I can’t say what they are.”

Hunt said on Talkline that as the elected authority figure in the office, he stepped in nine times to sign transfer documents that had fallen behind on final disposition. He acknowledged doing so in about nine instances and said he would have done so for anyone.

“So the auditor sitting in equity, me, decided we’ll sign the deeds rather than get sued and go to court. Create a little bit of you know a little bit of savings in the in the court system and maybe a few savings in our bankroll as far as as our defense of things,” Hunt said today.

He continued, “I’m the boss; I’ll take the heat.”

Capito commended the investigative work of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations. Assistant United States Attorneys Jonathan T. Storage and Joshua Hanks are prosecuting the case.

The indictments include allegations that Caudill allegedly made materially false statements to FBI agents during an Oct. 26 interview about the disputed tax deeds, including about whether he asked state auditor’s office staff “who will be the whistleblower” regarding the handling of the disputed tax deeds.

Cole is alleged to have made made materially false statements during an Oct. 6 FBI interview about the disputed tax deeds and about approving Hoffman’s falsified government time sheets.

The bank fraud counts allege that beginning around May 5, 2025, and continuing through about Sept. 29, 2026, Hoffman carried out the timecard scheme while aided and abetted by Hunt and Cole.

A full-time employee of the state auditor’s office,  is alleged to have Hoffman left her government duty station on Friday afternoons during the time period to perform paralegal and administrative work at the Mark A. Hunt & Associates law firm.

The counts further allege that Hunt and Cole also frequently worked with Hoffman on Fridays at the law firm during state business hours.

As a result of the scheme, Hoffman received compensation from the West Virginia Treasury, via the bank serving as its primary designated state depository, for work that she did not perform for the state auditor’s office, the indictments allege.

Mike Pushkin

The West Virginia Democratic Party also said Hunt and his associates should resign.

“The West Virginia State Auditor’s job is to investigate waste, fraud and abuse across state agencies — not to be the creator of waste, fraud and abuse,” said Democratic Party Chairman Mike Pushkin, who is also a state delegate.

“For Mark Hunt to remain in office under these circumstances would be like leaving the fox in charge of the henhouse. Mark Hunt, David Cole, Frederic Caudill, Marie Ann Hoffmann and Robert Johns should resign their public positions immediately.”





More News

News
Bloom: State acknowledges jail bill errors identified by 12-county coalition
Monongalia County Commission President Tom Bloom says it could mean millions.
November 16, 2026 - 2:16 pm
News
Northrop Grumman to increase production at W.Va. facility
November 16, 2026 - 1:52 pm
News
WV National Guard pays tribute to Spc. Sarah Beckstrom with community service in Charleston
Beckstrom was killed while on duty in Washington, DC last year.
November 16, 2026 - 10:52 am
News
Supreme Supreme Court rejects further review of tourism zones related to Hill Top House project
Last month, justices on the state Supreme Court considered arguments over whether the tourism development zones law improperly strips local regulatory authority and voting power to benefit a single private luxury hotel project.
November 16, 2026 - 8:33 am