Lawyers for state officers being sued over West Virginia’s school funding system say the case should be dismissed.
The West Virginia Attorney General’s Office filed a motion to dismiss late last week.
A lawsuit filed in September by attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union-West Virginia asks state Supreme Court justices to mandate that the Legislature and state officials reform the entire public school funding system to eliminate statewide funding inequities.
Article XII, Section 1 of the West Virginia Constitution explicitly states, “The Legislature shall provide, by general law, for a thorough and efficient system of free schools.”
The ACLU case contends West Virginia is not living up to that standard and was filed as a straight shot to the Supreme Court, asking the justices to force other state officials to fix school funding.
In recent years, West Virginia has again faced widespread school funding shortfalls, driven largely by an enormous deficit in special education costs and leading to school closures and consolidations all over the state.
West Virginia schools are largely funded through a seven-step formula that is based largely on student population. Total student registration has dropped by 8,270 pupils compared to the prior year.
Education officials have warned that 8 to 20 schools face closure or consolidation across West Virginia in the coming year.
Last month, the state Department of Education rolled out a detailed framework to update West Virginia’s school funding methods, intending for the proposal to be a starting point for legislators to take up.
The state Attorney General represents state officials like the governor and legislative leaders who are named in the education funding lawsuit.
In the latest filing they argue that the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction because legislative immunity shields lawmakers from being sued over the creation, amendment or rejection of statutes.
“Legislative immunity prevents the courts from considering actions brought against legislators that challenge their legislative acts, and it limits this Court’s jurisdiction,” wrote lawyers for the state officials.
“Every allegation that Petitioner asserts against the Legislative Respondents concerns the drafting, enactment, and amendment of the school finance statute. Immunity thus deprives this Court of jurisdiction over the Legislative Respondents, and the Court should dismiss them with prejudice.”
Lawyers for the Attorney General also contend that the petitioner, which is an unnamed student in Lincoln County public schools, has failed to establish proper standing because of a lack of demonstrated direct harm or verified taxpayer status.
West Virginia officials earlier asked the state Supreme Court to hold off until next spring to consider the lawsuit, suggesting that could give the Legislature time to handle the school funding issue.
ACLU-West Virginia, in a response filed earlier this month, urged a denial of the request to pause proceedings.
Those lawyers argued that holding off on judicial review is “neither efficient nor just” because students and schools have already endured years of broken promises and delayed funding reforms.
Waiting for the Legislature to act on its own creates a risk that lawmakers will spend significant time reaching policy consensus on reforms that still fail to resolve structural constitutional deficiencies, wrote lawyers for ACLU-West Virginia.
Court intervention prior to the coming regular legislative session would clarify constitutional obligations and guide lawmakers toward a compliant system, ACLU-West Virginia contended.
“For years, West Virginia’s students and schools have been given false hope and empty promises concerning reform to the school aid formula, always being told that an adequately funded education is right around the next corner,” the ACLU-West Virginia lawyers wrote.
“Despite this, the promised relief has historically failed to materialize.”
If the Supreme Court should choose to grant the motion and hold off on the case until spring, ACLU-WV requests that it issue a preliminary injunction to prevent the Department of Education and State Board of Education from approving school closures while the case is paused.
“Protecting schools from closure while changes to the school funding formula are underway will help to ensure that the affected parties will not suffer irreparable harm while watching another Legislative Session pass, waiting to see whether their elected officials keep their word,” the ACLU-West Virginia lawyers wrote.

