MetroNews Hotline   Watch |  Listen

Hunter gets a rare second chance at a coalfield buck

GILBERT, W.Va. — A Mingo County hunter figured when he blew his shot at a massive buck earlier this season and his chances were over. However, fate smiled on Nick Christian of Gilbert and he was able to bag the biggest buck he’s ever laid hands on in 2026.

The story started last year when the same buck had an impressive rack. Christian was after him and a second buck which were together patrolling his in his hunting area in Logan County very close to the Mingo County line.

“To be honest I would have shot either one, but I ended up killing that other deer around the first of November so I couldn’t hunt him anymore,” Christian explained.

However, through the summer the big buck stayed in the same area. Christian’s trail cameras captured image after image and video after video of the buck in velvet. But there had been a dramatic change in the buck’s rack. The 2025 rack was completely typical with no real anomalies other than a split G-2 on the right side. But something had happened and the 2026 edition of the buck’s antlers were a mess. The right side antlers were identical to the previous year with the split G-2, but the left side was a different story. The left side had the single brow tine, but growing from those was a double main beam. The front beam featured three points and a drooping, rounded point on the back side. The rear part of the split main beam featured three points.

The change made the deer all the more desirable to Christian who enjoys pursuing those big bucks which have made the coalfield counties in West Virginia famous. The area where he hunts is right on the Mingo/Logan County border, but he was hunting in Logan County.

“I actually had one encounter with him a couple of weeks before I killed him. He came in about 10 yards behind me like big bucks do downwind. I had a doe come in and she kept looking behind me, so I knew there was another deer back there. When I turned he was standing 10 yards away with his nose in the air. He just walked off,” said Christian.

In frustration, he left the woods. His 16-year old on tried to offer some consolation suggesting, “…you’ll get another chance at him.” But Christian wasn’t buying it.

The bucks’ 2025 race was completely typical other than a split G-2 on the right. The 2026 version had a left hand side which was hard to describe PHOTO: Submitted

“The chances of seeing a deer like that is once in a lifetime. To see him twice and actually get a shot is never going to happen,” he told his son.

But what Christian didn’t realize was while he may have spooked the deer that morning, the buck hadn’t left the area. In fact, he was catching him regularly on the trail cameras. Two weeks later in the early morning hours, Christian’s phone went off while he sat in the stand. It was the camera within site of him at that very moment.

“It was barely daylight enough to get a shot on him. I could see the big body and that rack and I thought, ‘Oh gees. there he is.'” laughed Christian.

He drew back, carefully placed the pin, and sent the arrow. It looked like a good hit. But when Christian got to the spot to check for blood, there was none to be found. There was also no hair.

“I started second guessing myself, there was no way I could screw this up twice,” he said.

Soon his dad and son arrived and his dad sent him back to his blind to direct them to where the buck had stood. Turned out they were looking about ten yards away from the spot. When he directed his dad to where the shot had occurred, there was hair and blood. They began to follow the blood trail and after about 20 yards, both he and his father saw something at the same time lying ahead on the forest floor.

“Me and my dad both looked over at the same time and it looked like a dead log laying there which was actually his back. About that time I could see his horns sticking up. Needless to say I took off running and screaming with everything in me,” he laughed.

The buck’s impressive rack was scored by a two man certified team under the Buckmaster’s scoring system and rounded out at 200 3/8th. Christian said once the 60 day drying period is over he plans to have the big buck scored under the Boone and Crocket system to see how he stacks up to some of the biggest killed in West Virginia.





More Outdoors

Outdoors
Logan native has an awesome trip back home to start archery season
Logan native comes home to unlock the secrets of a buck which nearly died of EHD and thanks to an online video gained near celebrity status with a viral video
November 13, 2026 - 3:48 pm
Outdoors
Youth season produces an almost perfect 50-50 harvest
Youth hunters kill 1,383 antlered and 1,381 antlerless deer during the first season of the split youth hunting season
November 9, 2026 - 9:40 am
Outdoors
Teen Luke Stewart wins the BASS Nation State Championship
The senior at Clay County High School bested a crowded field which included some of West Virginias best bass fishermen.
November 8, 2026 - 2:37 pm
Outdoors
Bailey's resignation leaves a third vacancy on Natural Resources Commission
The seven member commission is down to four members as the final meeting of the year is scheduled for November
October 30, 2026 - 11:55 am