CHARLESTON, W.Va. — A federal judge has once again ruled in favor of the Big 3 prescription drug distributors and against the City of Huntington and Cabell County.

U.S. District Judge David Faber handed down a 243-page ruling Wednesday finding AmerisourceBergen, McKesson and Cardinal Health cannot be held responsible for the dumping of millions of opioid pills into the Huntington area contributing to the opioid epidemic that began more than a decade ago.
In his new ruling, Faber hearkened back to his previous ruling on the case following a 10-week bench trial in 2021.
“The evidence at trial showed that the volume of opioids coming into Huntington/Cabell from defendants was overwhelmingly a feature of the evolving standard of care,” Faber wrote. “Doctors, most of whom were acting in good faith in reliance on the prevailing standing of care, were prescribing opioids more often and in higher quantities to better treat pain.”
Faber said doctors wrote the prescriptions which patients took to a pharmacy to fill.
“Pharmacists, in turn, placed orders with these distributor defendants to acquire sufficient opioids to fill those prescriptions. Distributors did not see individual prescriptions; they received bulk orders for the opioids they sold,” Faber said.
The judge said “overprescribing—and not illegal prescribing—drove the volume of opioids coming into Cabell/Huntington.”
Faber said Cabell/Huntington was not able to prove with any “competent evidence” that the drugs came in by illegal prescribing.
The plaintiff’s attorneys wanted Faber to look at the case through a “different lens” after it was returned to him by the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals.
“You made factual findings based on an incorrect standard that the defendants proposed,” Plaintiff’s attorney Paul Farrell told Faber in a hearing this past May.

He argued the different lens is now the Fourth Circuit agrees with the federal Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) that opioid distributors have the obligation under the federal Control Substance Act (CSA) to block suspicious orders of opioids, which Farrell said didn’t happen in Huntington-Cabell during the throes of the opioid epidemic.
But attorneys for AmerisourceBergen, McKesson and Cardinal Health all argued nothing had changed about the original case and urged Faber to once again rule in their favor.
AmerisourceBergen attorney Robert Nicholas called the Huntington-Cabell’s attempts to prove the Big 3 are at fault is based on “paltry, inaccurate evidence.”
“High prescribing is not evidence of wrongdoing,” Nicholas said in the May hearing.
Charleston attorney Steve Ruby, arguing on behalf of Cardinal Health, told Faber the testimony and the evidence are still the same when 70 witnesses were called to the stand in the 2021 trial.
“The plaintiffs have failed to prove their case,” Ruby said in May before Faber. “There’s no path to prevail under any legal standard.”
Faber’s new order said Cabell/Huntington was unable to prove what the Big 3 did was unreasonable.
“Their theory of the case was essentially that the volume of opioids distributed was in and of itself unreasonable. But how can it be unreasonable for a wholesale distributor of opioids to fulfill bulk orders for opioids that are used to fill prescriptions written by doctors in good faith? And while there is a natural tendency to assign blame in cases like these, they must be decided not based on sympathy, but on the facts and the law.”
Farrell told MetroNews Thursday the plaintiffs are disappointed with Faber’s decision but it wasn’t unexpected. Farrell said they will appeal once again to the 4th Circuit.
“Judge Faber has done his job. He’s been asked to reconsider. He reconsider and chose to stick with his opinion so we’ll take it up to Virginia, to the appellate court and see what happens,” Farrell said.
The lawsuit was first filed in 2017. Farrell said Thursday he’s not going anywhere, the fight will continue.
“If there are people out there that think that in West Virginia we quit–they’re wrong,” Farrell said. “We’re a stubborn people. We’re a pride people. We know the difference between right and wrong and there is no quit in this.”
Farrell said there will be a third chapter.
“We’re not at the end yet. Let’s not write the prologue yet. Let’s see what happens when we go to Virginia (appeals court),” Farrell said.
Cabell/Huntington was not seeking a large monetary damage award but instead wanted the judge to order a 15-year abatement worth $2.5 billion to be paid by the Big 3.

