MetroNews Hotline   Watch |  Listen
5:06pm: MetroNews Sportsline

Lawyers suing over school funding say dismissing case would be a ‘constitutional coup’

Lawyers for state officers being sued over West Virginia’s school funding system say the case should be dismissed, and the attorneys who filed the lawsuit in the first place have responded to say that would equate to a “constitutional coup.”

A lawsuit filed in September by attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union-West Virginia asks state Supreme Court justices to mandate that the Legislature and state officials reform the entire public school funding system to eliminate statewide funding inequities.

Article XII, Section 1 of the West Virginia Constitution explicitly states, “The Legislature shall provide, by general law, for a thorough and efficient system of free schools.”

The ACLU case contends West Virginia is not living up to that standard and was filed as a straight shot to the Supreme Court, asking the justices to force other state officials to fix school funding.

The ACLU lawyers continue to say a constitutional ruling on that is within the Supreme Court’s authority.

“While textbooks, budgets, and legislators change, the West Virginia Constitution’s command that children be provided a thorough and efficient education stands unwavering,” wrote lawyers from American Civil Liberties Union-West Virginia in a filing this week.

“The judiciary is the mechanism by which this fundamental right is protected, and Petitioner respectfully requests that the State Officer Respondents’ efforts to evade review be denied.”

The West Virginia Attorney General’s Office, which represents state officials like the governor and legislative leaders who are named in the education funding lawsuit, filed a motion to dismiss late last week.

The Attorney General argues that the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction because legislative immunity shields lawmakers from being sued over the creation, amendment or rejection of statutes.

“Legislative immunity prevents the courts from considering actions brought against legislators that challenge their legislative acts, and it limits this Court’s jurisdiction,” wrote lawyers for the state officials.

In a newly filed response, lawyers from American Civil Liberties Union-West Virginia strongly disagree.

Their brief argues that the West Virginia Constitution grants the judiciary ultimate authority to review legislative actions and maintain the separation of powers.

And it contends that the West Virginia Legislature has a mandatory, non-discretionary duty to adequately fund public education, which forms the basis of the underlying lawsuit. American Civil Liberties Union-West Virginia asks the court to deny the motion to dismiss.

“Rarely does a procedural argument rise to the level of a constitutional coup, but the Motion to Dismiss filed by the State Officer Respondents in this matter should leave this Court, and this State, deeply concerned,” they wrote.

“To avoid enforcement of one of West Virginia’s most firmly established rights, the State Officer Respondents propound a thoroughly undemocratic portrait of state government. If the arguments of the State Officer Respondents prevail, the Legislature will have held itself to be the final arbiter of our Constitution, then used that self-proclaimed authority to insulate itself from judicial review.”





More News

News
Marshall Health Network signs intent to manage The Greenbrier Clinic
Leadership from both institutions emphasize that the initiative will protect the clinic's historical legacy while upgrading diagnostic technology and broadening healthcare access.
November 20, 2026 - 4:08 pm
News
Investigation underway after 'cybersecurity incident' impacts legislature's IT system
Situation discovered Thursday.
November 20, 2026 - 2:44 pm
News
Morrisey wishes deer hunters good luck heading into 2-week firearms season
Morrisey at Bass Pro Shop Friday.
November 20, 2026 - 2:20 pm
News
Maryland man pleads guilty to sex trafficking women into Eastern Panhandle
Sean Fox, 40, of Baltimore, Maryland, faces 15 years to life in prison.
November 20, 2026 - 12:49 pm