MetroNews Sportsline   Watch |  Listen

Solidarity Should Apply at Fort Martin, Too

Listen to “Solidarity Should Apply at Fort Martin, Too” on Spreaker.

The United Mine Workers of America is upset that the West Virginia Public Service Commission approved the Fort Martin natural gas power plant. That is the union’s prerogative, but its objections ring hollow, especially in the spirit of solidarity – a valued trait among union brotherhood.

UMWA President Brian Sanson issued a scathing press release Thursday.

“The PSC, the Governor and state politicians who voted for HB2014 just handed utilities a blank check to jack up working families’ electric bills so out-of-state billionaires can power their data centers,” Sanson said. “The truth is West Virginia’s Governor, and his political allies have continued to destroy coal jobs, allowed tech companies to write legislation that eliminated citizens’ rights to say no to data centers, and are now slapping everyday West Virginians with the first of many new monthly rate hikes to pay for it all.”

That’s a compelling narrative, but it does not match reality. A few points to consider.

NEWS: Construction on FirstEnergy’s $2.48 billion natural gas plant, solar projects expected to start next year 

First, demand for electricity is growing. Electricity is the lifeblood of a vibrant economy, and that growth gives West Virginia an opportunity to prosper through its creation. Will the proposed plant power a data center? It very well could and it may be one located in the state.

FirstEnergy has said it would negotiate a special contract requiring a data center to pay its share of the costs. What if that falls through? The utility still projects a capacity shortfall without data centers, though it would come later and be smaller; theoretically leaving capacity for sale in the market – a benefit for ratepayers.

Would the Union have objections if the proposed plant used coal? Doubtful. That matters in evaluating its pushback.

The utility chose natural gas because they concluded it was the most cost-effective option available. In utility circles, that analysis is called a levelized cost of energy study. It estimates what it costs to generate a megawatt-hour over the life of a power plant, taking into account construction, fuel, operating costs and how much electricity the plant is expected to produce.

FirstEnergy made its case to the PSC, and the commission granted its approval. That approval solidifies that the argument held merit based on economics, not political rhetoric.

Also of note, Sanson said little to nothing about the workers who produce and move natural gas, including union members and West Virginians. The plant will need fuel, and that demand supports jobs at the wellhead, along the pipelines and at the plant itself.

Is that solidarity? We’re only with you when we benefit? What of their benefit?

A new power plant also means new opportunities for the people who operate and maintain it. And the existing Fort Martin coal plant remains in operation. With demand growing, there is room for both, especially in this market.

On top of that, building a new plant means work for skilled union tradespeople. Doesn’t the UMWA care about them?

Justin Williams, director of Affiliated Construction Trades West Virginia, called the project “an investment in West Virginia workers.”

“This project will generate thousands of good paying construction jobs, in addition to the continued maintenance work at all the other First Energy properties, these jobs have and continue to support families, communities and workforce development opportunities for future workers. This project will help ensure (West Virginia) is positioned for future development, which will in turn help generate more jobs and opportunities for West Virginians to stay here. Skilled trades jobs are in the highest demand we’ve seen in generations, and West Virginia should do everything it can to support the growth of the construction industry and apprenticeships.”

West Virginians can judge the UMWA’s motives for themselves. But I doubt the average West Virginian would willingly pay more for electricity if a less expensive option could meet the same need.

The PSC got it right on this one. The plant will create work, much of it union work, and give electric customers a reliable source of power at the best price. The Commission now needs to make sure any data center the plant serves pays its share – there is no indication that either FirstEnergy or the PSC intend otherwise.





More Commentary

Commentary
The Mark Hunt Scandal Raises Questions About the State Auditor's Office
November 19, 2026 - 12:39 am
Commentary
Auditor can no longer fulfill elected duties
November 18, 2026 - 12:16 am
Commentary
WV Football Playoffs have a problem
November 17, 2026 - 12:40 am
Commentary
Vox Populi, Vox Dei: The Legislature Must Respect the People's Will
November 15, 2026 - 4:50 pm


Your Comments