Deflating defeat: Mountaineers squander 10-point lead in fourth quarter, fall on final play to No. 20 Houston, 34-31

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — Two weeks ago, bowl eligibility was well within West Virginia’s reach.

Now it looks to be a pipe dream for the Mountaineers.

In its final home game of 2026, WVU squandered a 10-point fourth-quarter lead, and No. 20 Houston got a 23-yard field goal from Jonathan Dimas on the final play to prevail, 34-31, at Milan Puskar Stadium.

“You just have to play better football. We haven’t played defense all year,” WVU head coach Rich Rodriguez said. “We’ll play defense for stretches, but not consistently. Offensively, we’ll have a little lull and you have to fight through that. If I looked at average field position, we’re probably dead last. Seems like we always have to go 75, 80 yards.”

The Mountaineers (5-6, 2-6 Big 12) have lost three straight and now need to win Friday at Utah to become bowl eligible. The second-ranked Utes enter Saturday night’s matchup at TCU with a 10-0 record.

Playing without quarterback Conner Weigman, the Houston (8-3, 5-3) offense was instead directed by true freshman Keisean Henderson, one of the top recruits nationally in last year’s class.

“There’s a lot of moving parts and Keisean did an incredible job,” Houston head coach Willie Fritz said.
“Some guys would hear outside noise and would have gotten frustrated outside the lines. ‘When am I

going to get my opportunity?’ He just kept working every single week, got his opportunity and he was

ready. So I am just really really proud of him. He did a super job.”

With the Cougars trailing 31-21, they took over at their own 13-yard line with inside 12 minutes to play and Henderson helped guide a much-needed scoring drive that culminated with a Makhi Hughes 3-yard touchdown run for what marked his third score of the day.

WVU regained possession with 5:25 remaining and a three-point lead, but after picking up one first down, Mountaineer quarterback Michael Hawkins Jr. was stopped for no gain and shaken up on a play that forced him to leave for good.

Hawkins had been questionable for the matchup midweek as a result of a bone bruise to an ankle, but he was removed from the official injury report before kickoff and played every offensive snap until the team’s penultimate possession.

Hawkins’ injury forced quarterback Scotty Fox Jr. into action, but the next two plays netted 2 yards, forcing the Mountaineers to punt. 

“Same foot, bone bruise he had,” Rodriguez said. “He’s a tough kid. He tried to go back in, but it hurt him too much.“

WVU got the ball back at its own 10 with 2:01 remaining after forcing a punt, but it was unable to get a much-needed first down that would’ve at the least likely allowed them to at least force overtime.

Instead, Bryan Hansen’s ensuing 50-yard punt was poorly covered and returned 22 yards by Trent Walker, who allowed his team to start at the WVU 34 with 1:34 remaining.

The Cougars picked up a pair of first downs that forced the Mountaineers to use all three timeouts, before Dimas booted the game-winning field goal on what was essentially nothing more than a point-after attempt.

“We had to have another score or two obviously,” Rodriguez said. “Disappointed. The defense had some stretches. We didn’t do the field goal block the way I wanted it done. I don’t know if we’d have blocked it anyway, but there’s no reason not to execute the field goal block the way we’re supposed to.”

WVU led 24-21 at halftime and increased its advantage to 10 points after Hawkins’ 10-yard rushing TD on the first series of the second half.

The Mountaineers had separate possessions with a chance to add to the double-digit lead, but the first ended with a punt and the second with Jack Cassidy missing a 42-yard field goal attempt on fourth-and-3.

“If I had to do it over again, I’d have probably tried to go for a first down and not the field goal and tried to go up a little bit more,” Rodriguez said.

Dimas made a 34-yard field goal to bring UH to within one score, and the Mountaineers followed by punting from midfield on what marked their third of five straight scoreless series to end the game.

“The defense was able to adjust to some of the stuff we were doing,” said WVU tailback Cam Cook. 

Henderson capitalized on a coverage bust to throw a 68-yard touchdown pass to an uncovered Amare Thomas on the third play from scrimmage, allowing the visitors to settle in early and lead 7-0.

“Open up the game, try to get the crowd into it and what is it, three or four plays? It’s really deflating,” Rodriguez said. 

WVU wasted no time offering a response, which came on Cook’s 8-yard TD run to pull the Mountaineers even 3:12 into the matchup.

Hughes allowed Houston to lead by seven again with a 21-yard touchdown run on the team’s third series, while Cassidy made a 31-yard field goal in the final minute of the first quarter to cut the Cougars’ lead to four.

Cook broke off a 29-yard run on the Mountaineers’ first series of the second quarter and it helped lead to Hawkins’ 3-yard touchdown pass to John Neider, giving West Virginia its first lead at 17-14.

Hughes’ 2-yard TD run put Houston back on top, before Amari Latimer scored on a 3-yard run one play after DJ Epps had rushed for 44 yards. 

That enabled the Mountaineers to lead 24-21, but after Dimas’ 54-yard field goal attempt missed off the upright 58 seconds before halftime, the Mountaineers were unable to move the ball and settled for a three-point lead at the break.

Henderson completed 18-of-28 passes for 268 yards and Hughes rushed 19 times for 158 yards as the Cougars piled up 490 total yards, including 290 in the first and final quarters.

“I don’t think you can play quarterback in this day-and-age without having a high football IQ,” Fritz said. “I think [Keisean] showed that today. He made very few mistakes for playing in a Big 12 game on the road.”

Hawkins was 14-for-26 with 130 yards, while Fox did not complete a pass on two attempts.

Cook rushed for 131 yards on 25 carries. Hawkins added 98 yards on 18 attempts and Epps had 73 yards on five rushes.

WVU converted 4-of-15 third downs, though it was 2-for-2 on fourth down.

“This game was there for the taking,” Rodriguez said. “They’re a good football team. Disappointed we didn’t finish the deal like we could have. It would’ve been a great win.”





More Sports

Sports
WVU posts runner-up finish at NCAA Cross Country Championships
Trio of Mountaineers earn All-American status.
November 21, 2026 - 3:15 pm
Sports
Follow along: No. 20 Houston rallies for 34-31 win at WVU
Mountaineers fall short on final play.
November 21, 2026 - 12:34 pm
Sports
West Virginia welcomes No. 20 Houston for final home game of 2026
Mountaineers' quarterback Michael Hawkins Jr. is good to go, while Houston quarterback Conner Weigman is labeled questionable.
November 21, 2026 - 8:15 am
Sports
Highlights: Elkins outlasts Winfield in 2OT, Tigers clinch first state semifinal appearance
November 21, 2026 - 2:14 am