High School Football
  •    
  • Class AAAA
  •    
  • Class AAA
  •    
  • Class AA
  •    
  • Class A
Listen Now: MetroNews Midday

Muller in court Monday; decision expected on pleas to 4 counts of murder

CLARKSBURG, W.Va — A hearing in Harrison County Circuit Court Monday could result in the sentencing of a man who’s pleaded guilty for his involvement in a 2013 quadruple homicide or could restart the process of a trial.

The outcome will depend on the pleas offered by Sidney Arthur Muller, 29, of Fairmont, to two counts of first degree murder and two counts of second degree murder are accepted.

Sidney Arthur Muller
Sidney Arthur Muller

Judge Thomas Bedell did not immediately accept those pleas back in August, but did not reject them either, saying he wanted to look over the findings of a presentencing investigation completed Oct. 1 to make an informed decision.

The case’s origins date back to July 2013 when Muller was arguing with Todd Amos and Christopher Hart over a drug debt in a Clarksburg home along Locust Ave. and a gun was pulled on him. The Marine Corps veteran took the gun away and shot the two men dead, according to investigators.

Hearing the gunfire, Fred and Freddy Swiger –a father and son newspaper delivery team on their normal route– arrived at the scene, only to be killed by Muller as he attempted to flee.

Authorities were able to track Muller down and arrest him that same day in Marion County.

In the terms of the plea agreement between Muller and the state, the two first degree murder charges related to Amos and Hart would be negotiated down to second degree murder, which carry a sentence of 25 years to be served at the same time.

The two first degree murder charges related to the Swigers would carry life sentences to be served simultaneously to one another, but after the second degree murder charges.

However, Muller would have the potential for parole after serving the first 25 years, right before the life sentences begin.

Judge Bedell made a point in August to tell Muller that if he does accept the pleas, that parole is by no means a guarantee.

The families of Amos and Hart were in agreement with the deal, while the ex-wife of Fred Swiger, who is the mother of Freddy, wasn’t sure of her position ahead of the August 17 hearing, according to Assistant Prosecutor Traci Cook.

Monday’s hearing is scheduled to begin at 10 a.m. and if the pleas are accepted, it will lead directly into sentencing. However, if the pleas are rejected, Muller has the option to withdraw them and either wait for another deal to be presented or take the case to trial.





More News

News
State officials urge West Virginia justices to dismiss school funding lawsuit
Legislative leaders claim immunity shields them from school funding lawsuit.
November 18, 2026 - 12:51 pm
News
Treasurer Pack lays out legislative priorities in advance of 2027 session
Legislative session begins on January 13.
November 18, 2026 - 12:13 pm
News
Wood County cruiser destroyed by a passing motorist on I-77
November 18, 2026 - 11:01 am
News
First federal court hearing is set for indicted West Virginia Auditor Mark Hunt
The hearing is set before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dwane Tinsley. The U.S. District judge assigned to the case is Thomas Johnston.
November 18, 2026 - 9:38 am