Hearing set Monday on motion for Buffey to withdraw pleas to 2002 conviction

CLARKSBURG, W.Va. — A Harrison County man is scheduled to appear in court Monday morning as a circuit court judge will rule on him withdrawing guilty pleas related to a 2001 robbery and sexual assault.

Defense lawyers for Joseph Anthony “Joe” Buffey, 33, of Clarksburg, filed two motions last week.

Joseph Buffey is expected to withdraw his pleas Monday.
Joseph Buffey is expected to withdraw his pleas Monday.

The first requests he be allowed to revoke his pleas to two count of first-degree sexual assault and one count of first-degree robbery, while the second would grant Buffey to be released on bond and be put on home confinement with electronic monitoring.

Reports indicate prosecutors representing the state in Harrison County filed a response to the second motion Friday stating they do not oppose bond and home confinement.

Buffey was 19 back in December 2001 when he was arrested for a robbery at the Salvation Army in Clarksburg which took place near the home of the 83-year-old woman who was robbed and sexually assaulted multiple times that same night.

His attorney’s argued hours of interrogation by police related to both events led to a confession in which the testimony didn’t exactly line up with the timeline or evidence. He would later admit his confession was a lie.

The defense further argues that Buffey received poor counsel from his court-appointed attorney, giving him the impression that if he pled guilty to both crimes through a plea deal, the sentence would be just as long for both crimes.

A 70-year sentence was handed down, which he continued to serve as of Sunday.

It later came to light that during the process leading up to the acceptance of the plea deal, the state did not disclose DNA evidence potentially exonerating Buffey.

Another man, Adam Bowers, would be convicted using that DNA evidence in May 2015 and would also be sentenced to 70 years in prison roughly four months later.

Upon learning of this evidence, Buffey reached out for help in securing the right to withdraw his pleas.

The New York-based Innocence Project and Morgantown attorney Al Karlin got involved in the case and made an appeal which made its way to the state Supreme Court of Appeals in October 2015.

The court ultimately ruled in Buffey’s favor, writing in its majority opinion that “The Court finds the State’s failure to disclose the favorable DNA test results obtained six weeks prior to (Buffey’s) plea hearing violated the Petitioner’s due process rights.”

Filing a motion in Harrison County to withdraw the pleas was delayed after state Attorney Patrick Morrisey requested a hold on the courts ruling while they determined if they wanted to make an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The AG would eventually make the decision to not file a petition, saying “I remain concerned about the consequences of the state Supreme Court’s potentially broad ruling and hope the court will reconsider or narrow its decision in the future…This matter now rests with the local prosecutor.”

It’s unclear how Harrison County prosecutors will proceed with the case. Previously, they have maintained a two-attacker theory in which both Bowers and Buffey (while wearing a condom) assaulted the woman.

Monday’s hearing is scheduled to begin at 8:30 a.m. before Judge Thomas Bedell.





More News

News
Extradition delayed in Wheeling bank robbery case
Defendant having problems understanding legal proceedings.
November 21, 2026 - 11:10 am
News
Morrisey makes appointments in Commerce, DEP
Those appointed have been working for the state.
November 21, 2026 - 9:49 am
News
West Virginia National Guard pays respects to late Spc. Sarah Beckstrom at wreath-laying ceremony
Members visited Beckstrom's gravesite in Grafton Friday.
November 21, 2026 - 9:02 am
News
Lawyers suing over school funding say dismissing case would be a 'constitutional coup'
Brief argues that the West Virginia Constitution grants the judiciary ultimate authority to review legislative actions and maintain the separation of powers.
November 20, 2026 - 4:46 pm