Delegates say they unanimously voted against a big tax bill because Gov. Jim Justice practically dared them to, because they had serious concerns about the policy specifics and because their constituents overwhelmingly opposed the plan.
Governor Justice, several times recently, has said the 0-100 vote last week to kill the bill amounted to “grandstanding” and a missed opportunity. The governor says he’s going on the road to West Virginia communities to persuade citizens to see the bill as he does.
“I could give a hoot in every way what the House did with their grandstanding effort,” Justice said this week.
That drew a pointed reaction from Delegate Marty Gearheart, R-Mercer, who spoke out on the House floor against the tax shift.
“Grandstanding???” Gearheart tweeted. “In meetings for months, the governor has been advised that the House has no appetite for tax increases!”
Grandstanding???? In meetings for months the Governor has been advised that the House had no appetite for tax increases! He didn’t listen! In the words of my sainted Mother, “if you don’t listen you have to feel”!
— Marty Gearheart (@MartyGearheart) April 15, 2021
The governor’s rejoinder doesn’t tell the whole story, agreed Delegate Lisa Zukoff, D-Marshall.
“I heard overwhelmingly from my constituents that they didn’t want the PIT reduction in order to pay additional taxes on goods and services,” Zukoff wrote on Twitter. “My ‘no’ wasn’t personal, simply representing those who elected me.”
I heard overwhelmingly from my constituents that they didn’t want the PIT reduction in order to pay additional taxes on goods and services. My “no” wasn’t personal, simply representing those who elected me.
— LisaZukoffWV (@ZukoffWV) April 15, 2021
That is similar to comments several of her House colleagues have made in recent days.

Justice, a Republican, made an income tax cut the focal point of his State of the State address. Justice then pushed a big income tax cut offset by increased and expanded sales taxes. He says a swift income tax phase out would make West Virginia a popular destination for people to relocate.
The state Senate, with a Republican supermajority, narrowly voted in favor of the plan last week, 18-16.
The House of Delegates, which also has a Republican supermajority, then unanimously voted it down. Delegates expressed concern about the effects of the increased sales tax. They had planned to just quietly table the bill, but then put it to a vote after the governor said at a midday Friday briefing that delegates should be ashamed of themselves for letting it fizzle.

“House members thought that was very overreaching. That was not something we were going to tolerate. It was not something we were going to be a part of,” said Delegate John Hardy, R-Berkeley, speaking this week on “Panhandle Live.”
“The governor took to social media and was saying some pretty unkind things about the House members, so we took that opportunity to send the message to the governor and the Senate to say this is not a piece of legislation that we were interested in.”
The governor has publicly expressed his displeasure every other day since the vote.
“For us to be childish and say ‘Oh we all got together and showed the governor and everything,’ it isn’t a matter of showing the governor. It’s a matter about the importance of what this is for West Virginians,’” Justice said Wednesday.

The governor’s statements haven’t been persuasive, said Delegate Dianna Graves, R-Kanawha, who facilitates the meetings of the House Republican caucus.
“Our issue with the governor’s tax plan is that our members want to see a tax plan that responsibly cuts taxes, not just engage in tax swaps,” Graves said today.
“The governor kept saying ‘trust him because he loves us.’ I’m not willing to trust my constituents’ pocketbooks to anyone, no matter how many folksy sayings are thrown at me. And anyone who repeatedly says ‘trust me’ is probably someone you shouldn’t trust. We want to see facts and have numbers that make sense.”
Graves said she might have been open to continued debate on the Senate’s plan. She was intrigued by a reserve fund that would have built up until it could be used to lower income taxes. With more time, she said, compromise might have been achievable.
“Instead, what we had was a governor whose temperament and tactics torpedoed it by calling House members cowards and leveling insults at specific people who certainly didn’t deserve it. He wanted it up for a vote before a compromise could be reached — and he got it,” Graves said.
“I find it funny the Governor keeps claiming the House was intimidated by lobbyists, because what I think you saw with that vote was the House standing up to bullying and outside influences.”

Delegate Brandon Steele, R-Raleigh, said delegates put the tax bill up for a vote after the governor questioned whether they had the fortitude.
“We’re not afraid to take a vote on anything. I think that’s why we as a leadership team put that out there: fine, if you want to put that out here, here you go,” Steele said on “Radio Roundtable” on WJLS-AM.
“Find one person who wants to vote for your plan. They’re not here. We don’t take well to bullying. It’s as simple as that. You’re not going to bully us into raising taxes on the people we represent.”
The tax swap was a major factor in how delegates viewed the bill, Steele said.
“You’ve got a supermajority of conservative Republicans, not Democrats. We’re not here to raise taxes on people. That’s what his plan did. It didn’t cut anybody’s taxes; it just changed the way they paid them,” he said. “You’re not going to have a supermajority of conservative Republicans vote for the plan.”
He described a town hall he attended with community leaders who expressed little, if any, support for the tax bill. “I didn’t have one person have a positive thing to say about that tax plan. I can’t find a person that wants us to do that plan.”
Now the governor says he’ll hit the road to persuade citizens that the plan will put money in their pockets. Steele predicts an uphill battle for that effort.
“He’s got a heck of a job in front of him if he thinks he’s going to suddenly change their perception of what is a tax shift rather than a tax break,” Steele said.

Delegate Mick Bates, a Democrat whose district is next to Steele’s, agreed with many of those points. He said the governor should have been aware of the House reluctance to the bill.
“No means no. We’ve been telling him no the whole time,” Bates said this week on “Radio Roundtable.”
“Now he’s gonna go out on the road. He needs to talk to us, not the public. I can tell you what the public thinks. And him talking to them isn’t going to change their minds.”

Delegate John Williams, D-Monongalia, said he understands the governor’s passion about the issue “but sometimes you’ve got to look and assess the situation and see that it’s not there.”
“I believe it’s coming from a good place with the governor. He thinks it’s a good issue,” Williams said on “Talk of the Town” on WAJR Radio. “But he needs partners on this issue. And 100 delegates from one chamber of the Legislature just don’t think it’s a good issue.”
Williams said very few of his constituents in the Morgantown area have expressed support for the tax plan. “I’ve had maybe one out of 200 emails on this personal income tax plan say they want this. The others are ‘Please don’t do this.'”

House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, said delegates would be willing to continue consideration of cutting the personal income tax. But he said the step would be so significant that making any move will require time and research.
Insulting the delegates won’t help, Hanshaw said today on MetroNews’ “Talkline.”
“It certainly hurts the cause,” Hanshaw said. “Governing is serious business to be done by serious people. Ad hominem attacks on the very men and women who will be voting on a tax plan is no way to conduct the very serious business of this state.”

