Representatives of two power companies have identified additional expenses and the likelihood of a more restrictive timeline for taking over the Pleasants Power Station, which is set to close in a few weeks.
Monongahela Power and Potomac Edison submitted a new filing Friday afternoon to the state Public Service Commission calling into question aspects of a deal to take over the power plant in Pleasants County.
Earlier, in a March 31 filing, the companies had asked for a surcharge on ratepayers for about a year during work to determine whether taking over the power company would make sense for them.
The power companies said they have been working on a letter of intent with Energy Transition and Environmental Management, a remediation and industrial demolition company currently in charge of the Pleasants Power Station property.
“During this time, the companies have been made aware of potential additional costs and significant risks that the companies did not anticipate in the March 31 filing,” wrote attorneys for Monongahela Power and Potomac Edison. The filing said the companies cannot go into much greater detail because of a non-disclosure agreement.
Meanwhile, the companies also indicate the timeline is even tighter than originally expected.
The power company’s corporate owner, Energy Harbor, has been bought by another company, Vistra Vision, which wants its nuclear plants but not its coal plants like Pleasants. Right now, Pleasants is being shifted to Energy Transition and Environmental Management for possible shutdown and demolition.
Monongahela Power and Potomac Edison note that Energy Harbor’s lease with ETEM only extends to May 31, but the complications of hammering out an agreement could require discussions beyond that date.
“Therefore, the companies and ETEM have a very short window to enter into (a letter of intent) to keep Pleasants in a suitable condition to return to normal operations in the future while the companies complete their evaluation and develop a recommendation on next steps,” the power company representatives wrote.
Part of the agreement could require the power companies to reimburse ETEM for maintaining the plant in condition to be returned to normal operations if Monongahela Power eventually takes ownership. If the power companies decide not to take over, the agreement could include fees for ETEM.
If that agreement can be reached, the power companies are asking the Public Service Commission to approve it.
“It will take additional time for the companies to be able to determine if (a letter of intent) can be negotiated and finalized with ETEM,” the power companies wrote.
“Due to the complexities associated with negotiating these issues among multiple parties and completing the necessary due diligence, particularly with respect to environmental matters and engineering challenges, it is possible that this effort goes beyond May.”
The companies say that means an expedited review process of the agreement will be necessary, assuming agreement is even reached.
“If the companies determine that a reasonable agreement can’t be reached, the companies will also provide an update to the commission in a similar timeframe,” wrote the power company representatives.
“In that eventuality, a surcharge to customers will not be needed, and the companies will book a regulatory asset for any costs incurred after a commission order and will seek recovery in a future regulatory proceeding.”

Emmett Pepper, policy director of Energy Efficient West Virginia, had already been skeptical of the surcharge on ratepayers. With the late Friday update, he was incredulous.
“FirstEnergy was already asking the PSC to write a blank check to buy this plant, with a significant amount of undefined costs being paid using Mon Power and Potomac Edison customers’ electric bills,” Pepper said.
“But with this update, the amount of the blank check is going to be way, way bigger. With no information about the magnitude or purpose of what is being asked for approval, the only rational outcome is to reject this entire proposal as being a bad deal for the customers who would have to pay these costs.”

