Commentary: SB 460 oversteps in attempt to regulate private and parochial school vaccination decisions

West Virginia Senate Bill 460 goes too far in seeking to regulate private and parochial schools regarding religious and philosophical exemptions for vaccines. Private schools are just that—private. The government has no place setting conditions of enrollment for these institutions.
Senator Tom Takubo recognized this overreach and attempted to correct it in committee by proposing an amendment that would have allowed private schools to control their own policies. His amendment would have left the choice to each school: allow exemptions or not. This is the best solution, as it would let the market determine the fate of these institutions based on decisions made by their governing boards.
If a school permits exemptions, some parents may withdraw their vaccinated children. Conversely, if a school disallows exemptions, it may struggle to grow enrollment. This dynamic ensures that parents—not the government—decide the outcome by voting with their tuition dollars.
Instead, we have a supposedly conservative state senate that believes it should dictate the policies of private institutions. Nothing could be a greater infringement on freedom. Some have invoked the Constitution’s religious liberties and freedoms of speech and religion to justify this intrusion, but such arguments miss the mark. These constitutional protections exist to guard against government overreach, not to regulate private sector decisions. The correct role of government is to step back and allow natural consequences to shape outcomes, as described above.
A healthy debate on vaccines is fair. A debate on the impact of such policies on public schools is fair. But our state senate has crossed a far more significant line—one that extends beyond the vaccine issue. Without immediate correction, West Virginia will be in the business of imposing government controls on private enterprise. This measure should not be allowed to stand, as its continuation threatens the very foundation of freedom.

Editor’s Note: Dave and TJ will open the phone lines Monday on Talkline at 10:33 for listeners to offer their opinions on SB 460.





More News

News
Lawyers suing over school funding say dismissing case would be a 'constitutional coup'
Brief argues that the West Virginia Constitution grants the judiciary ultimate authority to review legislative actions and maintain the separation of powers.
November 20, 2026 - 4:46 pm
News
Marshall Health Network signs intent to manage The Greenbrier Clinic
Leadership from both institutions emphasize that the initiative will protect the clinic's historical legacy while upgrading diagnostic technology and broadening healthcare access.
November 20, 2026 - 4:08 pm
News
Investigation underway after 'cybersecurity incident' impacts legislature's IT system
Situation discovered Thursday.
November 20, 2026 - 2:44 pm
News
Morrisey wishes deer hunters good luck heading into 2-week firearms season
Morrisey at Bass Pro Shop Friday.
November 20, 2026 - 2:20 pm